Listener Stories: Vol. 117 featuring. For Better And Worse

Stories:

1: Help me tell my skeptic husband I’m a psychic - Nikki (she/her)
2: I will never tell my skeptic husband this story... - Mac (she/her)
3: “Quit it Suzy” – When a Skeptic becomes a believer - Katie (She/Her)
4: A Ghost Could Throw Him Across the Room and He'd Blame His Own Feet - Kristina (She/Her)
5: The woman in the laundry room wasn't my mom... and now my dad has some new beliefs. - Cait (She/Her)
6: The Time I Asked My Sister-in-law's Dead Dad to Grab My Skeptic Boyfriend's Ass - Tamara (she/her)


July is here and we are turning warts into wine with our ParaPods Network pals Rach and Jeri from the podcast For Better and Worse! Today we're sharing a batch of wild and slightly terrifying stories about skeptic partners, featuring bedside EMF detectors, ghost fingerprints, several woman spirits that will haunt our dreams, and even one encounter that left a skeptic with a whole new perspective on the afterlife. And does anyone else have partners that sleep like Victorian children or is that just us? …and that’s why we drink!

Want to hear more from Rach and Jeri? Listen to For Better and Worse wherever you get your podcasts, or you can find them before they find you on Instagram @forbetterandworsepodcast, on TikTok @forbetterandworse, or on YouTube at: @forbetterandworsepodcast


Transcript

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[intro music]

Christine: Well, hello everyone. Welcome to the July listener episode. That sounds shocking in my ears, but we’re apparently, uh, at this point when this comes out, more than halfway through the year. We have two very special guests from our lovely ParaPods Network. We have For Better & Worse. Uh, Rach and Jeri are here to help us dig into some skeptical ghost story relationship/ghost story/– I didn’t prep this part. Sorry, the adlibbing is not working for me.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Em: It’s okay. You– No, you’re doing great. You’re– Keep it, keep–

Christine: I sort of started to run out of steam, and I couldn’t find an entry– an exit point, so.

Em: Here. Tag team me. [holds hand up to camera] Tag team me.

Christine: [holds hand up to camera] Yeah, go ahead.

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: And now–

Christine: [laughs]

Em: –we are gonna be doing for our July listeners– Um, we, and by “we” I mean Eva, of course, as always, has picked out some wonderful stories for us, but the theme this time around is going to be, uh, relationships that you might be in with people that are either if you’re a believer they’re a non-believer or vice versa.

Rach: Mm.

Christine: Like a skeptical vibe. Yeah.

Em: And, um, because as you have heard Christine and I say for many moons now, uh, we are unfortunately, in a devastating blow, with skeptics, and, uh–

Christine: [laughs]

Em: –it has made our dynamics with them very interesting.

Christine: It’s, uh– Talk about, talk about a, a cross we bear every single day.

Em: It absolutely is a cross we bear.

Rach: It sounds crazy though, Christine, because isn’t your house haunted? Like how–

Christine: Oh, yeah. And my hu–

Rach: How–

Em: You would think– You’d think that would do it.

Christine: My husband will– You know wh– But here’s what I’ll tell you.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: He believes it more than anyone else. He’s just like, “I don’t want to know or think about it or have any–“

Rach: I’m like that.

Jeri: I was gonna say–

Rach: I’m like that. There’s a ghost in my house I’ve chosen to ignore.

Christine: Yeah. Yeah, yeah.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: He’s more like that where I’ve just learned like, oh, it’s not that he doesn’t believe it at all. It’s more that he’s just like, “I’d rather not even consciously think about it.”

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: See–

Em: I– You know, that’s better than what I’m dealing with over here–

Christine: Yeah, you’re d–

Em: –because Allison is just like, “Oh–“

Christine: I lived with Allison. She is a full-blown skeptic.

Em: Every time I think there’s a gho– My job is ghosts. She goes–

Rach: Right.

Em: –“Okay, so your job’s imagination, I guess.” [chuckles] Um, so–

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: “You’re so creative.”

Em: Yeah. It’s like, “Wow.” [chuckles] Um–

Jeri: “Good for you.”

Em: And it’s– I think it is, uh, very–

Christine: [chuckles] “It’s so creative.”

Em: A-as we mentioned in our emails, it’s very apropos to be doing this episode with you–

Christine: Yes.

Em: –because the two of you have one of these dynamics. Yes?

Christine: And also, well, tell us about your podcast. That’s more, that’s more on–

Em: Oh.

Rach: Oh. [unintelligible]

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –on theme, I think, of, of why we’re covering this.

Rach: Oh, that. That old thing.

Em: Hey, yes.

Jeri: So–

Christine: Oh, that old chestnut. [chuckles]

Jeri: [chuckles] I was gonna say, I don’t know if it’s worse to be in a relationship with someone who is a skeptic or in a relationship with someone who so deeply believes but is so afraid of it that–

Rach: Mm.

Jeri: –they’re like, “I don’t wanna know.”

Em: Hey. [points to themself] It’s me.

Christine: Oh, I, I know which one. It’s the one I have, I think, because I took Blaise to a Tyler Henry Hollywood Medium show recently. Actually, he took me for– It was a Valentine’s gift, and he did it– He, he did it ’cause I said, [whispering] “Psst, I want these tickets for Valentine’s Day.”

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs] Perfect.

Christine: And he said, “Okay.”

Jeri: We love a hint. Yeah.

Christine: Yeah. And so he took the hint, and he took me. And we walked out, and I said, “Oh, so what do you think?” Um, and he said, “I didn’t know that there’s something after we die,” and I went, “Ha-ha-ha.” And he said, “No, I’m serious. I had no idea. I just thought like we were computers and you just turned off when you died.” And I said–

Rach: Huh?

Christine: –“And you, you now like believe that?” And he’s like, “Yeah.”

Em: Where have you been? Whe– [chuckles]

Christine: And I said, “Well, haven’t you always like known that deep down?” He’s like, “No, I just needed to see that, and now I understand.” And I was like, “What kind of sick brain–“

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: Maybe it’s a healthy brain. I can’t really follow.

Jeri: [unintelligible]

Em: I, I love the m–

Rach: Clearly, he’s not a listener.

Em: The metamorphosis that is Blaise is incredible.

Jeri: Like, “I thought you’ve just been playing a real long–“

Christine: He just said like, “I had to see it with–“

Jeri: “–fictional game on your podcast.”

Em: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: I feel like he needed to–

Em: What’s this? The Sims?

Jeri: No.

Christine: –to see, see a medium with his own eyes, and he’s like, “Oh, shit. That guy’s really talking to dead people. They can–"

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: “–they can come back.” And I’m like–

Rach: Yeah. Jeri sees them herself.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Yeah, I know.

Jeri: Occasionally.

Christine: I do, too. I’m like, “Hello?” Okay. But all right.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: And I think he believed it, but he was just like, “I just didn’t really understand, and now I understand.” So I guess there’s growth there. Whereas with Allison, I feel like she’s put her foot down and said, “I don’t think so.”

Em: She is–

Rach: That’s–

Em: –steady.

Rach: I think that’s crazy. As someone who like I– I’ve said this to Jeri, I feel like some people are just more sensitive to that energy. I have a theory that like it kind of runs in family lines.

Christine: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Jeri: [unintelligible] Yeah.

Em: Mm.

Rach: And– But I’m the type of person that’s like pretty– Like I’m a pragmatist. Like I’m just like, okay– I, I take like data and I, you know, [unintelligible].

Christine: Yeah, that’s Blaise too, yeah.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: So many people believe in it. Like so many people have like–

Christine: Yeah.

Rach: –firsthand experiences or like– It’s be–

Jeri: So because of that it has to be true?

Rach: Yes.

Christine: And can I say something too? Only one of those experiences has to be real for something crazy to be happening. Do you know what I mean?

Em: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Like even if 95% of the people telling ghost stories, they’re like wrong or misconstrued or like didn’t understand– If 5% of those stories are true, like there’s ghosts, baby.

Rach: Right.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: That’s how we get laws.

Christine: [chuckles] That is how we get laws.

Jeri: We only have to have stuff happen–

Rach: Hey.

Jeri: –a small percentage of time for us to need to make a change.

Rach: Exactly.

Em: I– Well done.

Christine: Wow, that’s power–

Em: What a, what a slam dunk way to end that.

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: That– Talk about a rebuttal.

Jeri: This has been my platform. [chuckles]

Christine: I feel like if we were on debate team, we’d be so proud of ourselves and then like we’d immediately lose. Like someb–

Em: All of us–

Jeri: Oh, [unintelligible]

Christine: The other team would kick our ass.

Em: Jeri would have said that, and we’d all go, “Whew… That was gold.”

Christine: “Oh… Smoked ‘em.”

Em: “That was good.”

Christine: “Smoked ‘em.”

Rach: “We can go home now.”

Jeri: And I rest my case, Your Honor. Ghosts are real, goodbye.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs] And there’s no rebuttal allowed.

Em: You’re already– You don’t even get it. Like they’re–

Christine: Your Honor–

Jeri: Your Honor, please.

Christine: –are you even listening to me?

Rach: When we went to like ghostbust our house because the ghost was bothering our daughter, and our daughter–

Christine: [gasps]

Rach: –at the time was two.

Christine: [gasps]

Rach: And she was calling– She has a cubby in her room, which we thought, “Oh, so cute. Such a cute little cubby.” Um, but she would call it “Papa’s room.”

Christine: Oh no.

Em: Okay.

Rach: And– We do have a grandpa in her life that she you know– we call him Papa.

Christine: Uh-oh.

Rach: Never– He’d never been in that cubby. It seemed a little odd. Um, also it wasn’t a figure in her life at the time that he was around often, like probably like once a month, you know, like– We were like, “Okay, Papa’s room, Papa’s room.”

Christine: Different papa.

Rach: But I was like in–

Em: And does that mean she–

Rach: –there with her, didn’t feel anything negative until we were having some negativity. We were having some negativity right after my youngest was born, and we called in the ghostbusters.

Christine: You just mean like– Did you mean negativity like from the spirits or you’re saying you had negativity like in your family life?

Rach: Like Elsie didn’t feel negative about Papa. Like–

Christine: Okay.

Rach: –she didn’t feel like it was making her have bad dreams or anything.

Jeri: But then she got scared.

Rach: But then she started getting scared.

Christine: Oh, so it became more negative. Okay, I see what you’re saying. Okay.

Em: Sure. Okay.

Rach: Yeah, and like, “Whoa, whoa, whoa. [chuckles] That’s not cool, Papa. I’m not, I’m not down for that.”

Em: Mm-mmm.

Rach: “You can live in this house. I’m fine with that, but don’t be rude.” So then we called the ghostbusters, and we had a consultation. And he– To be fair, very honest. He was like, “Well, one of two things could happen, you know. We can go in. We can, you know, try to talk to the entity, see what’s up, and i-invite it to leave. Or it could ramp up the activity.”

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: [laughs]

Em: Yeah.

Rach: And I said, “Oh, thank you very much.”

Christine: There's no in between. [laughs]

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: I’m just gonna ask him to leave–

Em: Yeah.

Rach: –and I’ll do my best because more activity sounded–

Christine: We don't need that.

Rach: –horrifying–

Jeri: Oh, yeah.

Rach: –to me.

Em: And I, I, as, um, a-as someone who has minimal expertise in this, but I would usually assume that by talking to it at all you’re just– even if you’re trying to get rid of it–

Jeri: Feeding it the attention it wants, yeah.

Em: –you’re just stirring up activity by, by– Yeah–

Rach: Yeah.

Em: –by giving it the intention or by giving it permission to talk–

Jeri: Uh-huh.

Em: –all of a sudden or to, to make contact. I feel like it’s just–

Jeri: I like the phrasing “invite it to leave.”

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: Like it could decline the invitation.

Em: Mm.

Christine: I don’t like that.

Jeri: I’d just be like, “No, I–“

Christine: Yeah, I think you need to go in there–

Jeri: –“I think I wanna be more forceful.” [chuckles]

Christine: –and say, “This is my house.”

Jeri: “I think I wanna say, ‘You’re not welcome.’”

Christine: “Bye, Papa. Get out of your cubby, you little creep.”

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: And also, I’m wondering is it like– Is this thing like a– If, if Papa is real, if Papa is something that she’s seeing? I-Is it like just an old man that– so she’s assuming, “Oh, his name is also Papa”? Or is this like a doppelganger–

Christine: Ohh.

Em: –pretending to look like Papa? Because–

Christine: Ew!

Jeri: That’s what, that’s what I was gonna ask. Because if he presents himself as Papa–

Em: Because in that way, he– she feels safer.

Jeri: –or is it an assimilation thing where all old men are Papa?

Christine: Right.

Em: Right. But–

Rach: We’ve tried to get to the bottom of it. Um–

Christine: How old is she now?

Rach: Three.

Christine: Okay. Okay.

Rach: But she–

Em: Yeah.

Rach: And she still– It’s funny. She still calls it “Papa’s room,” which is just like, “Okay.” Um–

Christine: I hate that that stuck.

Jeri: This is an active case.

Rach: It’s an active case.

Christine: Oh, it’s an active case.

Em: [chuckles] Absolutely.

Rach: [unintelligible]

Christine: So wait. So have you asked him to leave?

Rach: I’ll probe about it. Like, “Oh, have you seen Papa lately?” And s– she just seems disinterested a lot of the time–

Christine: Ohh.

Em: Okay.

Rach: –in that conversation. So I’m taking that as a win.

Em: Okay.

Rach: Um–

Jeri: I don’t know if that’s a win though, because she is having night terrors. She’s struggling to sleep, and her not wanting to talk about it might just be–

Christine: Okay.

Jeri: –“I, I’m scared.”

Christine: Can I– As someone with a four-year-old daughter who I was prepped for any and all like Papa cubbies, like–

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: –“Oh, there’s someone in the corner.” Like, I was p– I was fucking ready. And I was like, “I live in a house from 1865. Like, some shit’s gonna go down.” And I was ready. Not a single word. And I’ve just thought, “Well, that’s weird. Maybe she’s like totally closed off.” I think it’s the same thing that Blaise has. Because I have asked her before– Like she has mentioned some weird things like some-sometimes she’ll say something like, “Where’s she going?” Like and point up the stairs, and I’m like, “Uh-uh,” you know? So there are like weird moments, but when I ask her anything about like her room or the house, she like kind of completely shuts down and w– is like–

Em: Mm.

Christine: –“I will not entertain this conversation.” [chuckles]

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: And it’s so weird ’cause like I’ve never presented anything as scary. Like we don’t, you know, watch anything– And she– It’s so weird because she’s very like insistent. And I– She has said since she was a little baby, “I don’t dream. I don’t close my eyes when I sleep. I don’t have nightmares. I don’t have good dreams. I just lay there, and I see nothing.” And I was like, “What the hell?”

Rach: What the hell?

Christine: So I don’t know if it’s like she has seen things–

Jeri: You know what?

Christine: –and is scared to talk about it.

Jeri: Ollie says that too. Ollie says when he sleeps, he leaves his eyes open, and he doesn’t sleep.

Christine: Are they as–

Em: What the fuck is going on?

Christine: Are they astral traveling?

Jeri: But– I know. I’m laying next to him, and his eyes are very much closed. Christine, I think we talked about this because–

Christine: We did talk about this.

Jeri: –we were talking about astral projecting and how we used to fly down the stairs and like kind of like go through–

Christine: Yes, you could float.

Jeri: –our house as kids.

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: And I don’t know if that’s what’s ha– what he means when he says, “I don’t sleep. My eyes are open.”

Christine: Same.

Jeri: Like he just–

Christine: I can’t believe that.

Jeri: –feels like he’s wandering the house. But he’s my kid who doesn’t talk about spirits where my other son–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –Forest, he’s–

Rach: He’s one.

Jeri: He wants to talk about–

Christine: That’s interesting.

Jeri: –everything.

Christine: ’Cause I always have a feeling if I a s–

Jeri: He wants to bring up this brother he’s never met.

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Mm.

Rach: He’s like all out.

Christine: See, like I know if I have a second kid, I feel like that’s the one who’s gonna be like, “ooh” [wiggles her fingers], you know.

Jeri: Uh-huh. [chuckles]

Christine: But Leona, for some reason, was like, “I don’t think so.” And so she and Blaise are like, “We’re actually not gonna go there.” And I’m like, “What is happening?”

Jeri: “What is this thing?” [laughs]

Rach: Right.

Christine: It’s so weird.

Rach: I– I’ve never felt sensitive to it–

Em: [chuckles]

Rach: –but my husband Josh has.

Christine: Oh?

Rach: Like he remembers being like– living in one of his mom’s house when he was growing up and like not going in the house. Like he would play outside. He hated being in there, like hated visiting–

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Oh…

Em: Hm.

Rach: –did not like it. So he has gotten confused through all this ’cause he’s just like, “I don’t sense any negativity.”

Christine: Ohh.

Rach: So it’s either like specifically pointed towards Elsie–

Christine: Right.

Rach: –or, you know, not– it– It’s not–

Jeri: That would be horrifying.

Christine: It’s just–

Rach: Yeah. I don’t know. The nightmares have gone down quite a bit.

Jeri: Well, that’s good.

Christine: That’s good.

Rach: We, we did do a salt ring around, you know. We–

Jeri: You did?

Rach: Yes.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: I was fucking terrified.

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: Like my, my–

Em: This is how I expected Christine’s motherhood to go.

Rach: Hearing your daughter– You’re feeding your newborn, feeding your newborn–

Jeri: Uh-huh.

Rach: –in their room, okay, and hearing your other– your not even two-year-old say, “Stop. I don’t like that.”

Christine: Ah! Like I would literally– I don’t know what I would do. I, I don’t know.

Em: Salt it up.

Christine: Scream.

Em: I, I get it.

Rach: P– Lay– Salt it up. Yeah.

Christine: Salt it–

Rach: Laying Piper back down and going in to Elsie and be like, “Are you okay?” And then–

Jeri: Salt Bae all day.

Rach: –“Come with, come with me.”

[Em and Christine raise a hand and mime sprinkling salt like Salt Bae.]

Christine: Sprinkle. Sprinkle a little salt.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: Yeah. Oh, it was [unintelligible].

Em: I, uh– Oh my god. So–

Christine: [sighs]

Em: –is that– That’s not happening anymore now though?

Rach: No. Like nothing negative–

Em: Okay.

Rach: –or like dramatic.

Christine: Phew. [sighs]

Rach: ’Cause after that experience of like that like activity– But what’s funny is it probably was like quite around like Halloween–

Jeri: Oh?

Rach: –time, if I think about it, ’cause Piper was a newborn.

Jeri: So he got more excited.

Rach: Yeah, he was more excited.

Christine: Ew.

Jeri: Papa, Papa’s playtime.

Rach: Papa’s playtime, you know. The veil– [unintelligible]

Christine: Gross. Jeri, you keep making it worse. Jeri keeps making it worse.

Em: Horrifying. Horrifying.

Rach: [unintelligible] or whatever.

Christine: Jeri keeps making it worse. Ow.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: Our podcast is nothing about any of this.

Christine: I know.

Rach: No.

Jeri: No, and that was like–

Christine: So, so, anyway.

Jeri: It’s fun to hear these stories because– Rachel’s not a skeptic, but she’s not–

Rach: I don’t have enough firsthand experience.

Jeri: I was gonna say if you don’t have enough firsthand experience, you normally don’t talk about it, and so you more just like observe and collect data.

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: And– So it’s interesting–

Rach: But I also avoid it. Like I think about people who like love scary movies and love– Like I don’t need any of that living in my head–

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: –ever. It’s scary [unintelligible].

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: It is scary enough.

Em: What, what’s crazy though is that I, I started this e-episode assuming that you were a total skeptic and yet you’re the only one who’s come in hot with a story that like actually is fucking horrifying.

Christine: [chuckles] Yeah, with a scary fucking story.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: And you’re like, “But I mean, I– you know, I’m thinking about it practically,” and I’m like, “I would not be, but okay.”

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: You know.

Em: Wild.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: You know.

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: So, um, the, the, the reason we started this– Rachel had actually started it years ago with her friend, Jess, um, as someone who was wanting to create content that she needed to hear herself–

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –after she’d gotten a divorce.

Christine: Mm.

Em: Mm.

Jeri: And so you had gotten a divorce. Jess had, uh, just– She was a newlywed, so it was the dynamic of 20s and 30s–

Rach: Right.

Jeri: –of like what’s going on.

Christine: Wow.

Jeri: And, um, Jess had some really hard things happen in her life, like back to back to back, and she was like, “Hey, I gotta go.”

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: “I can’t, I can’t process this shit on the internet.”

Em: Sure.

Jeri: And so after like a two-year hiatus–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –I was like, “You know what? You got remarried. I’ll get a divorce–“

Rach: [chuckles]

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: “–and then I’ll be the divorced one on the podcas–“ [laughs]

Em: For the content. Yeah.

Christine: Easy.

Em: For the content.

Rach: For the content.

Jeri: For the content.

Christine: For the c– For the story. Yeah.

Jeri: Yeah. I did it for the bit.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Wow.

Jeri: My children will appreciate that in the future. [laughs]

Christine: I’m sure they will.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: I’m sure they will. Wow.

Jeri: Yeah. So, so I–

Christine: So how’s it going?

Jeri: –I asked Rachel–

Christine: It’s relatively new, right?

Jeri: I was like, “Would you ever think about doing it again and–“ Yeah.

Christine: Yeah. A new reboot kind of.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Exactly. Yeah. And it’s been so fun. I love podcasting. It was like a hard exit when Jess left–

Christine: Mm.

Rach: –and, you know, we’ve kind of talked about that, like how, you know, it felt like a relationship, you know, ending–

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –whether– Like I wasn’t mad, and I wasn’t, you know, any way, but like obviously, there was that disappointment. But then–

Christine: Sure.

Rach: –getting the opportunity to start it again with Jeri and– You know, Jeri and Jess are very similar like level of friends, like–

Christine: Aw.

Rach: –met in a similar way. Her and Jess are similar age.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Like all of that. Um, so it’s been really fun to restart it and to, I don’t know, shift things in a way that like I wanted to at the time–

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: –and didn’t. And–

Jeri: And I even think the premise of the podcast being called For Better & Worse, a lot of times– We were also in the wedding industry, so we met–

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –because we were both wedding photographers. And a lot of times in vows, people say, “for better or worse,” and a lot of times “and” is the word because–

Christine: Interesting.

Rach: Yeah.

Em: Right.

Jeri: –it’s– a lot of times life is happening all at once. It's not an “or” situation; it’s always an “and.”

Christine: Ah.

Jeri: And I just loved– That’s why when I– When it was done, I was like, “It can’t be done.”

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: “There’s so much good that–“

Christine: It can't be over.

Jeri: “–[unintelligible] done with it.” So I– when I was going through my divorce and then I quickly was into another relationship– Actually, by this point in time, I will be married for a second time–

Christine: Yeah!

Rach: Yeah, yeah.

Jeri: –[unintelligible] this comes out. [laughs] Um–

Christine: July, I know. Oh my gosh.

Jeri: It’s– That’s– Whenever you said July, I was like, “Oh my gosh. I’ll be married for like–“

Christine: Holy crap.

Jeri: “–two months at this point.” Yeah.

Rach: Josh and I will probably have had our– [unintelligible]

Em: C– Well, congratulations, let us be the first–

Christine: Congratulations, yes.

Jeri: Thank you, thank you.

Em: –for your nuptials.

Rach: [unintelligible] anniversary.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: What the hell?

Jeri: Yeah. But I– Even in the, the exit of Jess, I think For Better & Worse is not just about marriages.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: It’s about all kinds of relationships. And I think you and Jess went through a big worse.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Rach: Yeah, a big worse.

Jeri: Jess went through a worse in her own personal life, and then having to navigate that with your friendship as she exited and still prioritizing that relationship. Um, and then when we went to Jess and asked for her blessing to start it again–

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: –like that was another–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –opportunity for, you know, us as a group of friends to kind of like navigate those things–

Em: Sure.

Jeri: –and just– It’s very hard being an adult, especially an adult woman, and navigating relationships and friendships and having a really core support group–

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –and so kind of wanting to give people that–

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: –in our little corner of the internet.

Christine: That’s so cool.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: It's the heart of it.

Em: It’s very sweet. Very sweet.

Christine: It’s just delightful. I watch all the clips on Instagram too. Like, I just– They– You guys just crack me up, so.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: Good.

Jeri: Thanks.

Christine: You’re a delight. You’re a delight. You’re both a delight. Um, wow. Well, we’re so happy to have you here, and we’re gonna read, um, on that note, stories that Eva picked about like people in relationships and, as we– I was gonna say hinted at, but as we just like totally– What’s the opposite of hinting at? Um–

Em: Bulldozed.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: [unintelligible]

Christine: –bulldozed the– [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: –bulldozed the theme of skeptic partners.

[glass clinks - start of ad break]

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[straw sucking bottom of glass - end of ad break]

Story 1 – Help Me Tell My Skeptic Husband I’m a Psychic

Em: This is from Nikki who uses she/her pronouns. Thank you for normalizing pronouns. And the subject line is, “Help me tell my skeptic husband I’m a psychic.”

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Ooh.

Jeri: Fun.

Em: Okay. So–

Jeri: Fun. Immediate fun.

Christine: [laughs]

Em: It’s– I, I was also, uh–

Christine: I knew you’d like it.

Em: It’s a bit of a, as Eva put it, a “Dear Abby” situation. Was that–

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: Nothing even happened yet–

Em: So–

Jeri: –and I got goosebumps. [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: The husband’s like, “I don’t think so.”

Jeri: I love telling men they’re wrong.

Christine: I know.

Jeri: I can’t wait. [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: Oh, Jeri’s like fucking chomping at the bit here. Let’s–

Em: Well, then shit. I don’t, I don’t even have to read this. Okay. Great.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Yeah. Why doesn’t Jeri read it? [laughs]

Em: Okay, here we go. Uh, “Long time listener, first time caller. My name is Nikki, and the skeptic in my life is my cis-male husband.”

Christine: Mm.

Em: And then, of course, she puts, “Go figure.” Um–

Christine: [laughs]

Em: “This is a long story, and I love to yap (I know you can relate), so I’m gonna get right to it. First, let’s address the subject line. Yes, you read that right. I think I might be a little psychic. I say ‘think’ because it’s kind of new. Well, not new exactly, but it’s like I just became aware of it again, if that makes any sense.”

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: “I’ve had intuitive feelings since I was very young. I also totally saw spirits when I was a kid, including the Hat Man.”

Christine: Cool.

Jeri: No.

Em: Uh, “But I digress. I eventually grew out of it like so many of us do. I also have some witchyness on my mom’s side of the family. My grandma used to tell stories about how her father could cure warts with the touch of his hand.” Ooh.

Christine: No, that means you have to touch someone’s warts though.

Em: Yeah. I– What–

Jeri: Couldn’t you do something more fun with your hands?

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: [laughs]

Em: Li– [laughs]

Rach: You probably could.

Christine: Maybe he had a lot of fun. Don’t, don’t yuck his yum, you know?

Em: Yeah. And–

Jeri: Well, I mean, there’s so many things that could be cured. Can we maybe try and focus on–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: And not that warts aren’t a good start.

Christine: Maybe he never, maybe he never gra– Well, Jeri, can you, can you heal a wart? ’Cause once you can heal a wart–

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: –maybe then you can talk about what level of healing your, your–

Jeri: Hey, how much time do I have?

Christine: [laughs]

Em: Well, once–

Christine: Okay. Here’s my wart. Hold on. [lifts foot up towards camera] [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: Once you can heal a wart, though, I’m mad that you can’t heal other things that feel like less hard to cure.

Jeri: That’s what I’m saying.

Christine: But–

Em: Like what about zits? Like you can’t handle my acne?

Jeri: [gasps]

Christine: Well, maybe he could. Maybe he just like had–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Maybe warts were like his–

Em: His specialty.

Christine: –expertise.

Em: Yeah. You’re right.

Jeri: Or maybe “wart” was just like a name for everything.

Rach: People came from all around.

Christine: Yeah, maybe warts–

Rach: People came from all around to get their warts cured.

Christine: They did, especially the warty.

Rach: You ever had a plantar’s wart? Brutal.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Brutal.

Christine: Can I tell you?

Em: You know–

Christine: I have one right now. I’m not even joking.

Em: You’re totally right. Maybe he can heal all things, but like one time there was like one wart that like everyone’s just remembered. They’re like, “That’s the wart guy.”

Jeri: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Christine: “Oh, that’s the wart guy.” Right, right, right.

Em: “Like he really handled that when–“

Christine: Like he– he’s typecast. Yeah, yeah.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: Yeah. He–

Jeri: He’s like, “I grew an arm back once, but all you guys wanna talk about is that wart.” [laughs]

Rach: “Is those warts.”

Em: [laughs]

Christine: So true. Oh my god.

Em: So. Uh, let’s see. Uh, he heals warts. Excellent.

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: “Story is–“ Oh. Ooh, here! We get a whole story about it. “The story is the wart would disappear within 24 hours after he touched you. It was a family secret that was passed down to the oldest grandchild for generations.” So like–

Christine: What?

Em: –if you’re the second oldest, fuck you, I guess.

Christine: Yeah. [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: If you have a wart, don’t ask any questions.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: Um–

Christine: See, this is why it sucks Leona’s the oldest grandchild ’cause she’s gonna be like, “I don’t care, and I don’t believe you”–

Em: Yeah.

Christine: –and then walk away, and no one’s gonna know the secret.

Jeri: “I don’t want this burden. I didn’t ask for this.”

Christine: Yeah. “I don’t, I don’t have a wart. Leave me alone.” Yeah.

Em: [laughs] Uh, let’s see. Uh, “More family witchyness. Growing up, my grandma told all of us grandkids that she was a witch. Uh, to give you a picture, my grandma was a little 5-foot-nothing sassy lady from Texas. She was exactly what you picture, sweet as can be but also scary as hell.”

Christine: [chuckles]

Em: “And she’d say all sorts of creepy shit to us. She would threaten to put spells on people who upset us or do, or do on to them if we didn’t behave.” Wait, hang on. “Or do, do them on us.” Oh, “do them on us,” do the spells on us, “if we didn’t behave.”

Christine: [laughs]

Em: I was like, “Hang on a second.” Uh–

Rach: Whoa.

Jeri: Threat. Threatening.

Christine: Threatening. [chuckles]

Em: “Then she’d just giggle– She’d just giggle and walk away and act like nothing happened” after she’s threatened children.

Jeri: Classic grandma.

Christine: Terr– Terri– Classic.

Jeri: Classic.

Em: “She passed away in 2020, but to this day, none of us know if she was kidding or serious. So now to some of my more recent experiences. Uh, as I said, I’ve always had a strong intuition, but it definitely got stronger when my grandparents passed away (and they died 40 days apart).”

Rach: Aw.

Em: Interesting.

Christine: Hm.

Jeri: 40 [unintelligible] nights.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: [chuckles]

Rach: Bible.

Christine: Noah’s ark.

Rach: Noah’s ark.

Jeri: Turning warts into wine or whatever they were. [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs] Plantar warts.

Em: “For example, one day a while back, I was in the shower, and I got a random thought about my great uncle Moose, which was his nickname for Morris,” which I love that you–

Christine: Great name.

Em: –made sure to tell us that.

Rach: Yes.

Em: Uh, “He was a man I met maybe five times in my life. The point is I barely knew him, so it was really random for him to cross my mind. A few days later, his daughter texted me to tell me he had passed away.”

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Mm.

Jeri: Aw.

Em: “Another time, I had a random thought about my husband’s dog, Nala, that he used to have with his ex. I met the dog once years ago before my husband and I were even dating, so it felt really random to think of, of Nala at the time. Same thing happened. His ex texted him a week or so later telling him that Nala had passed away.”

Jeri: Oh no.

Christine: Oh, they’re all stopping to say bye.

Em: Yeah. I– And– But it sounds like there are people who shouldn’t really like need her goodbye or want her goodbye–

Christine: I feel like that happens a lot.

Em: –but maybe she’s just like the, the– like the strongest magnet near them.

Christine: I was gonna say that happens a lot where like couples will dream of like their partner’s like grandma or somebody. Like it’ll like come through–

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: –a different person in their life–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –rather than directly.

Em: Mm.

Christine: Yeah.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Em: Maybe to help, help warn them or, or cushion the blow.

Christine: Maybe that’s like, like you said, the open person in the rela– like the open–

Em: Yeah. Or they’re like just the easiest to fly to or something–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: –that–

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: –they’re available that day. Um–

Christine: In the shower though, Uncle Moose? Like, hold on.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: I’m in the shower. Like, you don’t need to say bye right now.

Jeri: I’m opening my schedule for Uncle Moose to say goodbye.

Christine: Yeah. [laughs]

Em: I’ll always pencil Moose in. Yeah.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: “They’re, they’re not all about death. Uh, the one that fr– feels the craziest to me is that I predicted I was going to fall down some stairs.” Uh–

Christine: Oh my god. But imagine after Nala and Moose, you’re like, “Am I gonna die and I just predicted it?”

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: That’s terrible.

Rach: Feels more like a manifestation.

Jeri: Visualize my own death. Yeah.

Christine: Yeah. Manifest your own death.

Em: I, I would, I would be horrified anytime I got a flash of anything.

Christine: Mm-mmm.

Em: I’d be like, “What could it mean?” Um, “For weeks, me falling down stairs kept randomly popping up into my head. I kept thinking, ‘What the fuck is that about?’ And then I’d go on about my day and forget all about it. Uh, one day, I stumbled a little on some stairs at work and had the very clear thought, ‘It won’t happen at work.’”

Christine: Oh!

Em: Yuck.

Christine: Who is telling you this? Your higher self?

Em: Someone who obviously like has a mouth but not arms to catch you so you don’t fall.

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: I don’t know.

Christine: Wow, Em. That was poetic.

Jeri: “I’m not supposed to intervene.”

Em: [chuckles] It’s like, “I’m gonna just keep–“

Christine: Yeah, there– [laughs]

Em: “–horrifying you until it happens–“

Jeri: “Just the messenger.”

Em: “–and then watch it happen.”

Christine: The second you stumble down one step, they’re like, “Oh, by the way.”

Em: [laughs] “It’s now.” Yeah.

Christine: “It’s not now, but it’s later.”

Em: Um–

Jeri: “Have a nice trip. See you next fall.” [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: No.

Christine: Oh, you know, they were just waiting for that, that moment. Yeah.

Em: “I stressed the word, I stressed the word ‘clear’ because I have anxiety.” Oh, like, “I heard it clear.”

Jeri: Mm.

Em: The, the voice is very clear. “I stressed the word ‘clear’ because I have anxiety and ADHD. So you know, it’s loud as hell in my head–”

Christine: [chuckles]

Em: “–so clear thoughts stand out.”

Rach: Mm.

Em: Um, “I thought I was losing my damn mind. And sure enough, a few weeks later, I ended up falling down the stairs in my basement. Side note, I also ended up breaking my first bone, which I did not know would happen.”

Christine: [gasps] Oh, shit.

Rach: God.

Em: That part, that part was, uh, a secret little surprise for the moment. That was a–

Christine: Yeah, apparently, they didn’t want you to know that yet.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: Whoa.

Em: Um, “There are many more I could tell you, but let me not lose the plot. I still need your help with my husband.” Of course.

Christine: Oh, yeah.

Rach: Oh, yeah, yeah. That guy.

Jeri: Oh, yeah. Him.

Em: Of course.

Rach: That, that guy.

Christine: That guy.

Rach: Dump him.

Em: Uh– [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: –“as you can imagine, my husband is a typical man in the sense that he’s a very logic and science-based thinker. Not a bad quality to have until your wife starts thinking she might be psychic. I made off-hand comments our entire eight-year relationship about being psychic or a witch and he never shoots it down, but he doesn’t really buy it either.”

Jeri: Mhm.

Em: “And for the last few months, I’ve been basically exploring in secret.”

Rach: Mm.

Em: “I got an oracle card deck and have been pulling a card daily. I’ve been working on meditating and trying to connect to my spirit guides. I also have my first Reiki massage this weekend–“

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: Ooh.

Em: “–and my husband knows about none of it.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: There’s worse things you could be practicing in secret.

Rach: Truly.

Christine: I know. Imagine. Your secret life is just–

Em: Absolutely.

Jeri: Way worse things. [chuckles]

Christine: –like healing your– healing yourself.

Em: Yeah.

Rach: Yeah. Like sports betting.

Em: I wouldn’t even feel guilty about it yet if I were Nikki.

Christine: Sports betting. [chuckles]

Em: I’d be like, “This is just a vacay. This is just a selfcare experience.”

Christine: Definitely.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Definitely.

Em: “He’s a good man, and I know he loves me deeply, so I don’t know what my problem is. I’m feeling so apprehensive about showing this side of myself to him. So now I come to you, Em and Christine–” and Jeri and Rachel.

Christine: And we pass it off to two other people.

Em: Yeah. [laughs]

Jeri: Yeah. [chuckles]

Em: “–for your advice. How do I tell my very logical husband that I think I’m psychic? I’ll take any advice you got. And as a side note, I moved from Texas to Pittsburgh in 2023, and I spent much of that three-day drive listening to And That’s Why We Drink.” Oh, thank you so much.

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: Aw, good.

Rach: Wow. That’s a lot of, that’s a lot of you guys. That’s, that’s a long drive.

Em: Yes.

Christine: A lot of mi– mi–

Em: Yes, it is.

Jeri: Hey, I drove to Indiana one time to shoot a wedding and I listened–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –the entire time. I was in a Target–

Christine: I’m sorry.

Jeri: –trying to find something ’cause I didn’t pack correctly.

Christine: Yeah, is it weird when you–

Jeri: And that’s when I learned about the Backrooms for the first time, and I was like–

Christine: Ohh. It’ll–

Jeri: –“I hate it here, but I’ll be back.” [chuckles]

Em: You are welcome.

Christine: And it changed you.

Em: You are welcome.

Christine: And here you are. Here you are.

Jeri: Yes.

Rach: Um–

Em: Well, so thank you, Nikki. What, what advice does everyone have?

Christine: Hm, hm.

Rach: I think, for me, as someone who like I’m very practical, um– and it helps that like, like I said, I’m like, “A lot of people have this experience, so it can’t just be like bullshit.” Like–

Em: Right.

Rach: –saying something that’s bullshit because you don’t understand it is ignorant and dumb.

Christine: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: Like it just is. Like don’t be ignorant.

Christine: It's not like “science-minded.” right, right, right. It’s just like– Yeah.

Rach: I think specifically leaning into like the spirituality aspect of it– Like spirituality is a part of every single culture on the planet.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: Like just because someone doesn’t feel super tied to like a specific religion, like we can’t deny that as the human race, we aren’t drawn into some like spirituality of some kind.

Jeri: Something for nothing.

Rach: Right.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: Right.

Rach: Like every–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Rach: Literally every single early civilization on the planet had a higher belief system. Like–

Jeri: Well, I saw something that was like–

Rach: Like–

Jeri: –some people call it manifestation. Some people call it prayer. Some people call it quantum physics. Some people call it like all of these things, and it’s just an energy transference–

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: –and they’re saying– but nobody is saying that it doesn’t exist.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Right.

Jeri: No one’s denying the existence of it. They just call it something different.

Em: Right.

Jeri: And I think, in this situation, the reason you’re feeling– this is me assuming, making an ass out of you and me.

Christine: [chuckles]

Jeri: Uh, I think the reason that you are so hesitant to share it is because you are still–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –vulnerable about it. You’re still in self-doubt–

Em: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –and so you are afraid of rejection.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: And I would encourage you to not give a shit–

Rach: Right.

Christine: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Jeri: –because you do not have to share everything as far as like, um– You and your partner don’t have to do everything together–

Rach: Right, right.

Jeri: –all the time. As long as he’s not being dismissive or disrespectful of what you’re doing–

Christine: Yeah. They don’t even have to enjoy it. Like they don’t even have to enjoy it themselves–

Jeri: They don’t have to participate.

Rach: Uh-huh, yeah.

Christine: –just as long as they respect that you enjoy it. Right.

Jeri: Just respect me.

Rach: But saying that like, like, “I’m working on my spirituality. It feels something that’s important to me right now”–

Jeri: Uh-huh.

Rach: –is it– should be enough. Like, again, like I think the ten– like our the holistic view of self is like, you know, emotional, physical–

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –spiritual, and I think there’s another one. But like spirituality is always in there–

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: –for most people to feel like healthy, happy–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –and a full version of themselves. So–

Christine: I thi–

Rach: –if that manifests for her in like drawing cards and like–

Christine: Yeah, exactly.

Rach: –figuring it out, like that’s great–

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –and that’s special. And if that makes you feel more connected to yourself and the world around you, like your partner should be supportive of that.

Christine: I would, I would agree, and I would also add like I ho– I would also encourage you to not feel that you have to prove anything–

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: –like, “Oh, no, the cards really do work,” or you know.

Em: Right.

Christine: I feel like when I started this kind of spiritual journey, um, you know, and I was like– I wanted to prove like, “It’s not crazy. Like people– tarot really work–“ you know, and it’s like at a certain point, I realized like, “Oh. It is not my place to convince anyone else that it–“

Jeri: Right.

Rach: Right.

Christine: And also it doesn’t work. Like nobody– like I said, Blaise didn’t freaking understand that something happened after you died ’til he like had one particular experience and went, “Got it,” you know. Some people just–

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: Right.

Christine: –take to things differently. Yeah. So don’t feel like you have to prove anything to anyone, you know, um–

Jeri: Yeah, that–

Christine: –as well.

Jeri: –was all– I think you don’t need him to join you–

Christine: Right.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –in it. You just–

Rach: Yeah. You’re not asking him to–

Jeri: You just need him not to yuck your yum.

Rach: –to tarot. Right.

Christine: Right.

Em: Mm. Mm-hmm.

Jeri: And you need to be able to do it freely without feeling embarrassed like you have to hide it. Because it’s not something–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: It's more of you. And I think that’s the reason why it’s scary is– You talked a lot in the beginning about how deeply rooted it is in your family.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: It feels like a core part of you that you are exploring–

Em: Yes.

Jeri: –and that’s a really scary thing to wanna share with someone–

Christine: Totally.

Jeri: –and feel like they could dislike it. And so it’s not that you need him to join you. It’s that you feel that he needs– if he doesn’t support it, that it’s a form of rejection, and it’s not. Those two things need to be separate.

Christine: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Jeri: Like again–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –he just needs to be able to respect that you’re doing it.

Christine: It’s more important that you’re inte– Yeah.

Rach: And you shouldn’t be ashamed that you are doing it–

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: –just ’cause it’s new.

Christine: ’Cause you’re integrating it, not him. Yeah.

Rach: The only way to have a healthy relationship is to allow like growth and change within a relationship. It’s the only way that marriages, long-term relationships, partnerships last–

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –is because you allow yourself to grow and change. And I think it can feel daunting, you know. Like if I picked up like roller derby–

Christine: [chuckles]

Rach: –and started getting really passionate about roller derby–

Jeri: I love that.

Rach: –my husband would be like, “Okay, that seems out of nowhere.”

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: “Seems a little weird, but you are pretty aggressive and athletic, so–“

Jeri: “I love where we’re channeling this.”

Rach: “–you know, we put two things–“

Christine: Yeah. You know what?

Rach: “–put two things together.”

Christine: Good point, Rach. ’Cause maybe the partner– maybe the husband will be like, “Oh, yeah, that– I totally see that.” You know, who knows?

Rach: Yeah. As long as he doesn’t see it affect you negatively.

Christine: Maybe he– maybe he’ll have a reaction you don’t even know. Yeah. So who knows? Um, don’t let your own like mind talk you out of things. Sometimes–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –um, it likes to try to keep you safe, but.

Rach: But the longer you don’t say something, the more you feel like you’re keeping something. That’s when–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: And then it’s gonna feel bad, yeah. Yeah.

Rach: –weird stuff will come up about it. Like–

Christine: Yeah, agreed.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –“I’ve been keeping this from you,” and then it’s like, “Why would you?” You know–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –so don’t keep it to yourself too– for too long.

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: I also would like to say, before we go any further into giving advice, Rachel and I have no qualifications.

Rach: Zero.

Jeri: Sure.

Christine: [chuckles] Oh.

Jeri: We are not–

Rach: I have a bachelor’s degree.

Jeri: I have a bachelor’s degree as well, not in counseling. [chuckles]

Rach: Undergrad.

Christine: Oh, here you go.

Jeri: Not in giving advice.

Christine: Em and I have, um, master’s degrees in–

Rach: Mine’s in conflict management, to be fair.

Jeri: Okay, that’s good.

Christine: In what?

Jeri: That’s adjacent.

Rach: Conflict management.

Christine: I thought you said Catholic management.

Em: Oh my god.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: Catholic–

Christine: And I went, “Get out of here.”

Jeri: Yeah, she manages this Catholic every week. [points to herself]

Rach: Yeah, my dad too.

Christine: I was like, “I need help.”

Rach: Manage the ex-Catholics.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: Okay, just kidding. Yeah, that’s– I need help with that.

Jeri: My– Technically, my degree is as an intervention specialist.

Rach: Hey, we’re not unqualified. Like–

Jeri: And so when people hear that– Yeah. But it was for special education.

Christine: I was gonna say, “You’re farther–“

Rach: We’re not licensed.

Jeri: It had nothing–

Em: Sure.

Jeri: It has nothing to do with–

Christine: You are far more qualified. I, I was gonna say we have master’s degrees but in television. Like it’s not–

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Like we like f– to write fictional shit. This is not– We’re not–

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: But people who listen to our show–

Rach: Hey, that was my dream growing up.

Jeri: [unintelligible]

Christine: –already know that. Yeah.

Em: I was gonna say–

Christine: Well, hey.

Em: –it’s like a-a– there have been a few times when people have asked me ghost hunting advice, but they’re like, “Oh, I, I think I have like a demon in my house. What do I do?” And I’m like, “What do you do? I–“

Rach: Run.

Em: “Move. I don’t know.”

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: Move. Like get the hell out.

Christine: Burn it down.

Em: What are– How on earth–

Jeri: “Do I look like a priest?”

Christine: You’re like, “Don’t ask me–“

Em: Why, why am I the qualified person? I–

Christine: “–first of all.” yeah.

Em: But I, I guess like I– I’ve accidentally made some people think that, um, I’m an exorcist. So I–

Rach: Oh.

Jeri: Well, and that’s the thing–

Em: I don’t think any–

Jeri: –on the internet, people can say whatever they want and can talk about their experiences and– Like I know we talk a lot about our, our mental health disorders and whatever else. And I mean, I’ve diagnosed myself with several things on TikTok, but–

Christine: [chuckles]

Jeri: –and that’s why I think it’s very important to say like w– please do not– [chuckles]

Christine: Yeah, don’t take this as any professional–

Rach: No, I’m comfortable. You can listen to me.

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Yeah, you can–

Rach: I have a very good track record.

Christine: Hey, listen.

Rach: I have a impeccable– I have an impeccable track record.

Jeri: Oh, fantastic.

Rach: Okay? Don’t listen–

Em: Perfect.

Rach: –to my own advice most of the time, but when it comes to other people?

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: I was gonna say–

Rach: Oh my god. I–

Christine: –aren’t you divorced? [laughs]

Rach: I said to Jeri the other day as I like psychoanalyzed one of my friends who was in a new relationship, and I was like, “This is not good. This is bad news. Blah-blah-blah-blah-blah,” you know, gave her the spiel. Yeah.

Christine: It is sometimes a lot easier to see outside.

Rach: Yeah. She came to figure it out–

Christine: Yeah.

Rach: –and I was like, “Am I psychic?”

Em: That’s–

Rach: And then they were like, “It’s probably just your like autism packe– pattern recognition,” and I said–

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Oh. [blows raspberry] Tomato, tomato [pronounced “toe-may-toe, toe-mah-toe.”]

Rach: –“Okay, well.”

Christine: It’s always the autism, never the psychic abilities.

Rach: Psychic, autistic.

Christine: Yeah.

Rach: Could be both.

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Could be both.

Em: It could be both. You never know– And yeah, it is– it’s always, um–

Rach: It’s definitely one. It’s definitely autism. [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: At least.

Rach: Definitely that.

Christine: At least.

Rach: Got that diagnosis in the book.

Em: Alright.

[glass clinks - start of ad break]

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[straw sucking bottom of glass - end of ad break]

Story 2 – I Will Never Tell My Skeptic Husband This Story…

Em: Who would like to read the second, uh, story? Is that, uh– Should we–

Rach: Yeah, we can read.

Christine: Are you all reading any–

Jeri: I can go.

Christine: –or are you just– Oh, yeah. Okay. So Jeri, you can go next.

Jeri: I gotta pull it up. I have a whole laptop because I still have not–

Christine: Look how f–

Em: Perf.

Jeri: –been to the eye doctor.

Christine: Fancy.

Jeri: And so I can see–

Rach: Not to brag.

Christine: Not to brag.

Jeri: Okay, I’ll–

Em: It looks like we have pictures for, uh–

Christine: Mm!

Em: –the second story.

Christine: Pictures.

Em: So at some point, we’ll all have to–

Christine: Okay.

Em: –you know, take a look at the bottom.

Jeri: This is juicy.

Em: Okay.

Jeri: Hopefully, these images load.

Christine: Oh, oh. Eva sent the pictures in a group chat for after. Sorry.

Em: Okay. Perfect. Thank you, Eva.

Rach: Yeah, to–

Jeri: Okay, okay. Good, good, good, good. Okay. Alright. So this is– Am I allowed to say their name? Yep. Okay. This is called, “I will never tell my skeptic husband this story…”

Rach: Ooh.

Em: [gasps]

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Oh, good, but tell us, tell us.

Jeri: Hopefully, he’s not a listener. [chuckles]

Christine: But tell us. [chuckles]

Rach: Tell me. Tell me.

Em: [chuckles]

Jeri: I love a secret.

Em: That’d be so awkward if he, he’s like, “So I checked And That’s Why We Drink this week and, um–“

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: –“what’s going on?”

Jeri: “Mm, honey, I heard–“

Christine: “I heard four relationship experts–“

Jeri: “Hello Em, Christine, Eva, And That’s Why We Drink team, lovers of the weird, thirsty little rats, fur babies, and (sorry, Em) beloved Lemon.”

Christine: Yes.

Em: Okay. As long as you’re not a Scorpio, we’re fine.

Jeri: I’m gonna– I’m tagging myself as thirsty little rat, so–

Em: Great. That’s excellent. As a–

Rach: [chuckles]

Christine: I’m just a beloved lemon.

Jeri: You can be the, the lover of the weird if you want. [chuckles]

Rach: I already finished my drink, so I might be the thirsty little rat. [chuckles]

Jeri: Okay, perfect.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: “My name is Mac (she/her), and I am a long time listener, first time writer. I saw your request for stories about skeptic partners, and being a weirdo who is newly wed to a skeptic, I figured this would be a great time to share. To preface, I’ve always had, as my family calls it, the ‘touch.’”

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Oh?

Christine: The wart touch?

Jeri: Can you remove warts though? [laughs]

Christine: Yeah. [laughs]

Rach: Hey. [chuckles]

Em: [laughs] Excellent callback. Excellent callback.

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs] She’s a professional.

Jeri: “I would hear and see things that no one else could. I would have premonitions of the future and be able to just ‘know’ when something was going to happen.”

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: “This impacted me so much as a child that I even pulled my mother to the side once to speak in private about a visitor I had.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: "I regular–“

Em: Named Papa.

Christine: [chuckles]

Rach: [chuckles]

Jeri: Papa. Papa’s here.

Rach: Papa’s here.

Jeri: “I would regularly get visits from my grandmother who passed when I was a toddler – never menacing. She was just always there. Sometimes she would help me navigate hard things. Sometimes she would come with warnings. One day she warned me of a car crash.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “I saw her in my room. I could smell her brand of cigarette.” Classic.

Christine: Classic.

Em: [chuckles]

Jeri: “And I got these horrible flashes of a red car wrecked–“

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “–in the woods as a teenager, maybe 11 at the time, that didn’t make sense.” Tweenager. Oh my god. I was like, “Teenager at 11? What’s happening?”

Em: Love it.

Christine: Teenager? [chuckles]

Jeri: “I don’t think I understand what a teenager is.”

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: Okay. “Tweenager–“

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: Tweenager.

Jeri: “–maybe 11 at the time, that didn’t make sense. No one I knew had a red car, and I couldn’t drive yet. About a week later, around Halloween, my friends and I were getting ready to go to a haunted hayride. Right as we were getting ready to go, my friend’s mom got a call. The hayride was cancelled by the woman who ran it. She had just found out that her son had passed in a bad car accident.”

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Oh my god.

Jeri: Grandma came to say, “You’re not gonna be able to go to the hayride.”

Rach: [unintelligible]

Christine: I know.

Em: Yeah, yeah.

Christine: I was like, “What is the point? What is the message?”

Em: You know–

Jeri: [chuckles] “We were, we were bummed.” That’s what it says next.

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: “We were bummed”? [laughs]

Em: I sure bet. Oh my god.

Christine: Yeah, yeah.

Rach: How to soften this blow.

Jeri: “We were bummed–“

Christine: “Golly gee.”

Jeri: [chuckles] “–that our fun Halloween night was ruined and complained–“ [chuckles]

Christine: Oh.

Rach: Well.

Em: It– It’s one of those stories that at 11 it’s–

Christine: At 11.

Em: –it means one thing–

Jeri: Yes.

Em: –but then as you get older, it slowly morphs into like, “Oh.”

Christine: It’s not really funny anymore–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –when you get to a certain age and you’re like–

Jeri: I think, I think this is a very vulnerable thing–

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: –to do, to admit that this is how you felt–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –after you heard that– [laughs]

Rach: –somebody had passed. [laughs]

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: And we all would have been the same way at 11. We would have all been like–

Jeri: Oh, 100%.

Em: –“[sighs] Damn it, I really wanted to go.”

Christine: We don’t get it at all.

Jeri: “–as an–“ [laughs]

Christine: A tweenager.

Jeri: –“as angsty tweens do, so my friend’s mother showed us a photo of the car that was in the crash to, I don’t know, force us to empathize?”

Christine: Oh!

Em: Oh!

Jeri: So they show the car to be like, “Oh, this? Would you rather be here?”

Christine: Oh, my dad used to do that. My dad used to do that. He’d be like, “Oh, yeah. You feel sad? Look at these starving people.” And I’m like, “Why?”

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: “Could be worse.” [laughs]

Christine: “Why?” Yeah.

Rach: Why was “there are people starving in China” always the reason–

Em: Always.

Rach: –to get us to finish our–

Christine: It’s always.

Rach: Like–

Christine: And then when the internet came around, my dad’s like, “I can even show you pictures of it.” And I’m like, “Wha– Okay. Thanks.”

Jeri: Aw.

Em: Yeah. [chuckles]

Rach: Right.

Christine: Fucking weird.

Jeri: Okay. “It was the red car my grandmother had warned me about.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “I told my mom all of this, and she very nonchalantly looked at me in my distraught tweenage eyes and said, ‘Everyone in the family has that.’”

Christine: Oh!

Jeri: “We didn’t speak about it again, and I continued to navigate this weird ability on my own. Maybe I’ll share more of my stories in the future, but let me get on with this story.”

Em: Okay.

Jeri: “Flash forward to adulthood. I meet my amazing husband, and I am very clear about how I see ghosts and about my ability to just know things when we first meet.” I love the upfrontness.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: “Him, being not a complete skeptic as he believes in ghosts and did not question my ghost stories, but also not a full believer, he thinks psychics are BS. Uh, he’s always shrugged my visions off or reassured me when I have a bad or weird feeling that I’m just anxious–“

Rach: Mm.

Jeri: “–and then gets upset that I– ‘I’m always right’ when the exact thing–“

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: “–I said would happen happens.”

Christine: Wow. Wow.

Jeri: [chuckles] And then they say, “Men…” [laughs]

Em: I mean, it’s– we’re all thinking it. Yeah.

Christine: I mean–

Jeri: Uh-huh. [chuckles] Oh, yeah. “Even though he’s skeptical, he has always been a part of all of this. For example, when he and I met, my grandmother came to me the night of what should have been our first date. I had to postpone due to some life things, and I was worried I wouldn’t hear from him again. I was really contemplating just cutting my losses before he even got the chance to ghost me. But the familiar smell of her cigarette smoke filling the room and the happy little visions of he and I together confirmed that I had found the one and that he would stick around.”

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: “And three years later, we are now married.”

Christine: [gasps].

Jeri: Grandma was like, [pretending to smoke a cigarette] “Let me tell you about your husband.” [laughs]

Christine: Yeah. Take a long drag. I love–

Em: “He’s not gonna be perfect, but he’ll be good enough.” Yeah. [chuckles]

Christine: I love that she’s like, “Here’s a car crash. Also, here’s your beautiful marriage. You never know what I’ll show up with.”

Jeri: Yeah. Yeah, “I know all.”

Em: It’s, it’s like gamut– She runs the gamut.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: She’s like, “It could be something–“

Rach: Yeah.

Em: “–that will affect you minimally or just so significantly.”

Christine: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Rach: Yes.

Jeri: Yeah. Well, significantly, as a tween, that–

Rach: Hey.

Jeri: –probably was big.

Em: Sure. You know what? It’s significant to all. Yeah.

Christine: Yeah. To me, certainly.

Jeri: [laughs] It’s relative.

Rach: I mean, it was canceled for everyone.

Jeri: That’s true.

Rach: Not just them.

Jeri: That’s true.

Em: That’s true.

Christine: That’s so tr–

Em: It was a ripple effect.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: A lot of other people were bummed that day, I bet.

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: Big, big bummer of a day. [chuckles]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: That was just such a big bummer.

Jeri: “Now for the part I refuse to tell my husband. We eloped Halloween 2025 in a cemetery close to my first big girl apartment [chuckles] where we went often while dating–”

Christine: [chuckles]

Jeri: “–(we are both goth.)”

Christine: “My grandma showed up with her cigarette.” [laughs]

Jeri: I, I love this.

Christine: It’s just like–

Jeri: I love this. Like, “My husband’s a skeptic. We did get married on Halloween in the graveyard.”

Rach: Halloween in a–

Christine: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. “But I’ll never tell him my secret.” [chuckles]

Em: Nope.

Rach: Like I’m not buying that he’s a skeptic. That’s wild.

Christine: Yeah.

Em: Right.

Jeri: “We were going to wait a while, but I just had this feeling, this push that it needed to happen that day. So we did the thing, and it was beautiful. Just the two of us. We didn’t tell anyone we were eloping.”

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: “We invited all of our friends over to our house for a ‘Halloween party’ that night and surprised them with the news when they arrived.”

Christine: Aw.

Jeri: “It was a great night. And once the sun went down, we went out to the fire pit and decided to make a fire and roast some marshmallows. My friends and I were chatting as my husband walked around the border of our yard collecting firewood and sticks with a flashlight in hand. Then it was like something told me to watch him, told me to check on him in the yard. I looked up from the fire and saw him at the far edge of the yard. He was bending down to pick up a stick, and as he stood up, the flashlight came up with him and what came into my view made my blood go cold.” Agh. “There was a woman standing right in front of him, inches from his face.”

Em: Hey.

Christine: Mm.

Em: What?

Rach: Did he see this woman?

Jeri: “They were nose to nose, and he is over six foot tall.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “It felt like they stood there like that for ages, even though it was probably like ten seconds. She was terrifying. I had never seen her before. She was not my grandmother.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “She was pure white in a white tattered nightgown with white and gray hair covering her face. I couldn’t see her feet or her hands, and her face was featureless.” Blegh.

Christine: Blegh.

Em: I’m gonna throw up. What is happening?

Jeri: I know. I– [sighs] There’s like three more paragraphs. “And then–“

[all laugh]

Jeri: It’s fine. It's gonna be okay. It’s gonna be okay.

Rach: Getting better. Get–

Jeri: “And then as my husband put the flashlight down to get another stick, she was gone.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “I sat frozen in my seat as my friends chatted to me. When I finally unfroze, I excused myself to go inside. I salted and cleansed every door and window in my small house.”

Christine: [groans]

Jeri: “I told no one what was going on. I lit an incense, said a little prayer, and marched my terrified ass back out to the fire pit to check on my husband, who was totally fine and enjoying his fire building adventure.” Just a clueless man.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: Thank goodness for it.

Christine: Oh.

Em: Like honestly, for once, finally, you know what I mean.

Christine: Like, I mean, just humming, humming along. For once, it’s, it’s beneficial to all of us. Yep.

Jeri: Thank you. “We installed a camera on that side of the house. And I’m sorry to report that we have never caught anything on it.” I– Don’t be sorry.

Rach: Don’t be sorry.

Jeri: That’s great. I’m, I’m ha–

Christine: Don’t be sorry.

Jeri: –thrilled for you.

Rach: It's alright. It’s alright.

Em: Do not apologize.

Jeri: [chuckles] “I still have no idea who she was or what she wanted, but thinking about it chills me to my bones. I will never tell my husband what I saw. This is the first time I’ve really even ‘talked’ about it.”

Rach: [sucks in breath]

Jeri: Eugh. “I don’t–“ [chuckles]

Rach: I– Yeah.

Jeri: “I don’t know what kind of beyond the veil wedding present the universe was trying to give me–“

Christine: [chuckles]

Jeri: “–but I really could have gone without that. Thank you all for making me laugh and supporting the weird kids out there. Also, my sister would kill me if I didn’t give her a shout-out, so Taylor, I know you’re listening, love ya.”

Christine: Hi, Taylor.

Em: Hi, Taylor.

Christine: Whoa.

Jeri: “Please see the attached photos of my goofy animals, Shadow, the dog, and Lilith, the cat, to brighten your day, and a bonus photo of our wedding day so you can see how great it was pre-freaky ass ghost visit.”

Christine: I’m gonna s– look– Oh–

Jeri: Oh– Thank you, Mac. [looking at photos] Oh!

Christine: –my god.

Em: Very cute.

Jeri: Aw, very cute.

Christine: I’m trying to picture this man with a, with a witchy creepy–

Em: Yeah, truly.

Jeri: Person–

Christine: –demon lady.

Jeri: –nose to nose.

Rach: Yeah. I mean–

Jeri: –featureless nose to demon nose?

Rach: –I think– I mean, for the best. I don’t– I wouldn’t say. You know what I mean?

Em: Yeah, I wouldn’t say either.

Rach: I think it’s– I wouldn’t–

Christine: You know, remember when we said, “Oh, imagine he listened to this podcast”? Now he’s gonna be crying if he listens to this podcast.

Rach: Yeah. I don’t like that.

Christine: That’s so scary.

Em: I–

Jeri: Do you think something followed him home from the cemetery?

Christine: That’s what I sa– That’s what– exactly my thought, Jeri.

Rach: I think that’s the risk of getting married in the cemetery.

Christine: I was gonna say, I feel like something followed from the cemetery. I totally agree.

Em: Interesting. I mean, others–

Jeri: She was like, “I heard you wanted a bride?”

Em: [laughs] Yeah.

Christine: Yeah, exactly. I was like, I feel like–

Rach: She was wearing all white?

Em: “Forever. Eternity.”

Jeri: Yeah, she was wearing all white. Corpse bride.

Christine: She probably stepped between you while you were saying your vows.

Em: She was giving him a kissy, a little wedding kiss.

Rach: No, no, no.

Christine: Oh my god.

Jeri: “I do.” [makes kissing sound]

Rach: “I do.”

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Mwah! [laughs] Mwah!

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: Oh man. I just hate that. Um–

Christine: Yuck.

Em: I wonder what the– I’m, I’m– Although, it was– I can’t imagine it. It would– had to be horrifying to actually see, but I feel like I’m just left with more confusion ’cause I’m like, why is that something that the, the spirits felt that you needed to see but would not give you any more context? Like I wo– I wonder what it meant.

Jeri: Part of me feels like it had nothing to do with something for her.

Christine: I don’t think so either.

Jeri: Part of me feels like it’s just something that she witnessed.

Christine: She just had a feeling.

Em: Okay.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: She said, “Something told me to check on my husband,” and she looks up and is like, “Whoa. Something’s like feeding on him or something.” Yeah.

Jeri: “Oh, you’re here.”

Em: But I would spiral, and then I would go, was– were they telling me about that b– Like how come I haven’t seen any other experiences he’s had with spirits that he was unaware of? Is, is this the only one?

Rach: Hey, it’s a long life.

Em: Or was this significant compared to the rest?

Rach: It’s a long life.

Christine: Oh, Em. You would just–

Rach: You never know.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Yeah, you never know.

Jeri: What if–

Em: I’d spiral.

Jeri: –that was here in the future?

Rach: [gasps]

Em: [gasps]

Rach: And she grew taller.

Em: And she is six feet tall now.

Jeri: Well, she was floating. She didn’t have feet.

Rach: Oh. Ew.

Jeri: She didn’t have hands or feet.

Rach: What?

Christine: Yeah, but she had terrible energy.

Rach: I missed that.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: She had terrible energy though.

Rach: It’s horrid.

Christine: She had terrible energy though.

Jeri: Whenever–

Rach: I hope no accident happens.

Jeri: So I used to see a woman in white in my mom’s bedroom.

Rach: Oh lord above.

Jeri: And she–

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: I mean, she didn’t really have a face, but she also was floating. She didn’t have feet.

Em: She didn’t have a lot of things.

Rach: [unintelligible]

Jeri: She would stand at my mom’s mirror.

Rach: Jeri.

Em: So she’s looking at her, her face that has no features.

Jeri: She was looking at herself, yeah.

Christine: Okay. I’m looking at this wedding photo.

Em: She was going, “Where’s my fucking face?” That’s what she was doing in the mirror.

Christine: But I looked at this wedding photo, and like this person– she’s like significantly shorter. I don’t know. I don’t know if that’s– I feel like if the vibe is bad, I don’t wanna say that it’s her grown up.

Jeri: Oh, yeah. She did, she did feel s–

Christine: Some really–

Jeri: Sometimes I wonder like, is the vibe bad or are you spooked?

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Mm.

Em: I think that too.

Jeri: Or do you get spooked because the vibe’s bad? Do you know what I mean? Like what came first?

Christine: But also like if you’re– but if you’re getting– if you’re seeing your grandma and you’re seeing car crashes and you’re getting married in a graveyard, I feel like at that point you kind of have a– [chuckles] Like– Like if you saw a ghost, you wouldn’t immediately be like, “terrible, bad,” right?

Jeri: Do you think?

Christine: Like I feel like– Yeah, I mean–

Rach: Yeah, it’s like ominous.

Christine: I don’t know. It feels like it was tr–

Rach: Except I would guess the grandma to give good tidings of [unintelligible].

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Trying to be creepy.

Em: I would, I would think– I would look at my track record and be like if most of the time what I’m seeing is something like, let’s say, quote, “bummer,” I would–

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: –I, I would put this in the “bummer” category until proven otherwise.

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: I’ll also say she said that they were face to face for what felt like ten seconds.

Christine: That’s a–

Jeri: That’s a long time.

Christine: No, she said it felt forever, but it was probably like ten seconds. I’m like, ten seconds is–

Em: Is long.

Christine: –like you said, a really long time.

Jeri: Ten seconds is a very long time to be standing like this with a nothing. [holds her hand up right in front of her face] You know what I mean?

Christine: She said, “She was terrifying. I’d never seen her before. She was not my grandmother. She was pure white in a white tattered nightgown with white and gray hair covering her face. I couldn’t see her feet or her hands, and her face was featureless. And then as my husband put the flashlight down, she was just gone.” Eugh.

Em: I do, I do wonder– I, I, I wish that she, in the moment, had asked him like, “Hey, a– did you feel anything weird just happen?”

Christine: “Were you thinking of anything?” [chuckles]

Em: Like– Because for all you know that was the only time in his life that he has also felt something odd–

Rach: Yeah. Like, “Are you cold?”

Christine: Ooh.

Em: –and neither of you are telling each other.

Rach: “Are you very cold?” [chuckles]

Em: Yeah. [chuckles]

Rach: “Did you get a chill in your bones over there?”

Christine: “Hey, uh, how you feeling? Any goose–“

Em: “Did you feel a kiss? Did you get a kiss?”

Jeri: “Happy to be married to me?”

Rach: Yeah. [laughs]

Christine: “Any goose–“ [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Oh god. Okay. Well, ha–

Jeri: I thought a snake was gonna come up. When she was like, “I look up, and he’s in the grass with a flashlight,” I was like–

Em: I thought–

Jeri: –“Oh, he’s gonna get bit by a snake.” [chuckles]

Rach: I don’t think that’s [unintelligible].

Em: I thought there was gonna be a, I thought there was gonna be a yard accident for sure. Like she was–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Oh, I totally–

Rach: [gasps]

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Oh my god. I was like, I thought grandma was gonna come back–

Jeri: No.

Christine: –but no.

Jeri: Creepy faceless lady.

[glass clinks - start of ad break]

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[straw sucking bottom of glass - end of ad break]

Story 3 – Quit It, Suzy – When a Skeptic Becomes a Believer

Christine: Um, okay. So this is called, eugh, “Quit It, Suzy.” I don’t like that. Alright.

Em: I’m out.

Christine: [laughs] Bye.

Em: I just–

Rach: It’s the name, Suzy, I don’t like.

Em: You guys handle this one.

Christine: Yeah, it’s already bad. Uh, okay, so. “Hi Christine, Em, Fur Babies, amazing team at ATWWD,” Jeri and Rachel also.

[Jeri and Rach laugh.]

Christine: “My name is Katie (she/her, Libra.) First off, I wanted to start this by saying how much I love your podcast. Um, let’s crack into it. My ex-wife lost her–“ Oh, okay. Of course, now Suzy is just– Okay.

Rach: Oh, we like Suzy.

Christine: Now I’m an asshole.

Em: Okay. Got it.

Christine: Okay. Great.

Em: Yeah. I thought we didn’t for a second, but.

Rach: We take it back.

Christine: “My ex-wife lost her aunt Suzy quite suddenly. She had cancer and hid it from the family until near the end of her life.”

Jeri: [unintelligible]

Christine: “It was devastating, especially for my ex-wife. A few months after her passing, a lot of paranormal activity started happening at our home. Our touch light would turn off and on. Our EMF reader would con–“ [laughs] Our light and our EMF reader that’s also next to the light. It's just– [laughs]

Jeri: Our bedside table. That’s our bedside EMF. [laughs]

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Just our fam– It’s just our, our family EMF.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: This is the portable EMF. Yeah.

Rach: Just leave that on all night.

Christine: Our travel EMF.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Um, okay. So let’s see. “Our touch light would turn on. Uh, our EMF reader would constantly be going off, and our gas fireplace would switch on and off. It seriously freaked me out, but my ex-wife would always say, ‘That’s just Suzy.’ The only thing that convinced me this was not a demon was that my dog would always act the same way. His tail would start wagging. He would go into the spare bedroom and stand on his back paws as if he wanted someone to pick him up.” Aw.

Em: Aw.

Jeri: Oh…

Christine: And she’s like, “I can’t.”

Em: He’s showing his tummy. Oh!

Christine: Oh, baby. She’s like, “I don’t have hands or feet. I can’t pick you up.”

Em: That’s the worst part about being a ghost is you can’t pick up any puppies.

Jeri: He said, “Uppies.”

Em: [sighs]

Christine: You can’t even– “Uppies, uppies.” [laughs]

Jeri: “Uppies.”

Christine: “Uppies.” Okay.

Jeri: I love a puppy uppy.

Christine: Puppy uppy.

Em: I love it.

Rach: Oh, your dog is a baby, so.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: I’m gonna cry. Oh my god. “–if he wanted, he wanted someone to pick him up. After seeing this a few times, I started to relax a bit. However, it was getting very annoying.” [chuckles]

Jeri: [chuckles]

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: “So we then removed the touch lamp, EMF reader, and blew the pilot light out in the gas fireplace. During this time, we told my ex-mother-in-law, Suzy’s sister, what was going on. This woman was convinced we were lying and would always roll her eyes whenever we told people. She would always make the same comment: ‘If it’s true, how come I’ve never seen anything?’ My ex-mother-in-law would be at our house from time to time, helping with the kids, and nothing would ever happen. Until one day, my ex-mother-in-law was in the doorway of my daughter’s room. In the back of this room, there was an old lamp that had a switch on the cord to turn it on and off. It would always make a loud clicking noise when you did this. We were talking to my mother-in-law about more odd things that were happening, and she made another comment about how we were making it all up when we heard a loud click and the side lamp turned on. We all looked at the light. For a long time, no one talked until I heard my ex-mother-in-law say, ‘Okay, quit it, Suzy.’” [laughs]

Em: Okay.

Christine: It’s her sister.

Jeri: Suzy’s in the corner–

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: –middle fingers up.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Middle finger. She’s like, “Your sister–“

Jeri: “Here you go, you un-whimsical bitch.” [laughs]

Christine: “You can’t escape me. I’m your sister.”

Rach: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Yeah. What the fuck? Ca– Live a little.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: “‘Okay. Quit it, Suzy.’ Then another loud click and the light turned off.”

Em: Wow.

Christine: “That was the day she finally believed us. Odd things would still happen from time to time, but my mother-in-law never doubted us again.”

Em: Good.

Christine: “Sorry, this to–“ Oh, you know what? And I have advice for the first person too. Sometimes you just need– who wanted to know how to tell her husband. Sometimes you just need to like ask your, your team to be like, “Can you just help me orchestrate something that like will work?”

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: I feel like in this situation it’s like the mother-in-law’s like, “Why don’t I ever see anything?” Like she’s bound to see something.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: Oh, yeah.

Christine: Suzy’s like, “I’ll show you something.” You know?

Em: Yeah. I’m pretty sure you’re a family member.

Jeri: Yeah, that’s when you get ‘em, Suzy.

Christine: Yeah. Ge– Quit it, Suzy. [chuckles]

Rach: Get ‘em.

Jeri: Whoever your Suzy is, just a quick “get ‘em,” if you ever–

Em: Yeah. [laughs]

Christine: “Uppies. Uppies.”

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: [sighs]

Christine: It’s my favorite.

Jeri: Alright, Rach. [unintelligible]

Em: Well, wonderful.

Story 4 – A Ghost Could Throw Him Across the Room and He'd Blame His Own Feet

Em: Alright, Rachel, would you like to do the– number four?

Rach: Yes.

Christine: The honors.

Jeri: [unintelligible] –for you.

Rach: Okay. Let me– Scoochy. Scoochy scooch. Okay. Okay. This is from Kristina (she/her). “Hello And That’s Why We Drink family. My husband, Z, and I are high school sweethearts. I am the spooky spiritual one, and he’s the ‘there’s an explanation for everything’ one.”

Christine: [chuckles]

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: “Over the course of our relationship, several paranormal things have occurred in his presence. Let me share some of the stories I have, so we can roll our eyes together at this lovely clueless man.”

Em: Love it.

Rach: “Number one–“

Jeri: My favorite.

Rach: “–outright denial. I grew up in a haunted house. I experienced disembodied voices speaking in my ear and watched semi-transparent figures disappear around corners.”

Christine: Mm.

Rach: “I had told him–“

Jeri: [chuckles] Your face when you read that.

Christine: Right. Yeah. You literally shifted– like your– you left your bo– Your soul like was–

Em: [chuckles]

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –like, “I’m gonna hang out over here.”

Jeri: Your body took a screenshot.

Rach: I–

Christine: [laughs] That’s so good.

Em: [laughs]

Rach: SSRIs are not enough for these people.

Christine: No. [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: Like, if you’re seeing this shit, like it’s not doing enough.

Jeri: Speaking of SSRIs– I’m so sorry I’m derailing this.

Rach: Did you forget?

Jeri: Well, yes. But, um, so for the wedding, we are doing, um, like specialty cocktails–

Rach: Oh, yeah.

Jeri: –for Brady and I, like his and hers.

Christine: Oh, that’s so cute.

Jeri: And he’s doing a Jack and Coke. I am doing a paloma, but if you know anything about a paloma, they have grapefruit in them.

Christine: Uh-huh.

Em: Mm.

Jeri: And grapefruit and SSRIs–

Christine: You can’t do that.

Jeri: –don’t mix, so we are doing a pineapple paloma.

Em: Oh, fun.

Christine: Yes!

Jeri: Taking care of my people.

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: “Delcioso.”

Em: Very fun.

Christine: Also birth co–

Em: You have to think about those things.

Christine: It also fucks with birth control. We don’t want that on a wedding night.

Jeri: Exactly.

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: I’m thinking.

Rach: You’re thinking of everyone.

Jeri: Yeah. [chuckles]

Christine: Big brain. Big brain.

Em: You’re on, you’re on some other level. Absolutely.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: Okay. So you know, disembodied voices, figures disappearing.

Jeri: We’re back.

Rach: Okay. “I told him of these instances and more, and his response would always be, ‘I believe you’ve experienced something strange.’ Yawn.”

Christine: Oh, boo.

Em: Oh, come on.

Rach: Uh, “One day we were hanging out in my bedroom–“

Christine: You know what that sounds like? That fucking–

Rach: “–talking about a recent experience I had, and he outright said, ‘I just don’t think ghosts exist.’”

Christine: Argh!

Rach: “He got up to go to the bathroom, and my door forcefully swung open as he reached for the doorknob.”

Em: Good.

Christine: Told you.

Rach: “He briefly paused–“

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: “–turned to look at me, and said, ‘Well, that was weird.’”

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: Mm-hmm.

Rach: “He spent the rest of the night adding pressure to the floorboards on either side of the door in an attempt to recreate it.”

Christine: Oh, stop wasting your time.

Rach: “He opened windows in the room and on the bottom floor to create a draft. It did not budge.”

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: “To this day, he still thinks it was all a coincidence.”

Em: Or he– I mean, it is–

Jeri: This man loves the scientific method.

Em: It is absolutely, as stated, outright denial. This is like, you have to be kidding me.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Outright denial.

Em: Have to be kidding me.

Rach: But I can agree with the outright denial ’cause– and, and just kind of like I don’t see it. Like our Toniebox will turn on at random times–

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Rach: –and I’m just like, “What is going on with the Toniebox?”

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: I mean, I’m the same way, Rach.

Rach: Now, it could be Papa, wanting to, you know–

Christine: But I feel like if somebody said to me, “Oh, I– this thing happens, and I–“ I feel like his answer smacks of like, “I think you– I believe you believe what happened,” you know.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: And it’s like, you know, at a certain point like–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: I agree with you though. I am with you where I’m like, “Oh, must be a glitch. Must be a lighting–“

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: “–electrical issue,” u-until it’s like really– But, but the fact that he’s spending all night trying to prove it, it’s like he knows something. [unintelligible] sorry.

Jeri: You know what that– what he did reminds me of?

Em: Mm?

Jeri: It reminds me of when you accidentally like move your chair and it sounds like a fart and then you try–

Christine: Uh-huh.

Jeri: –and get it to do it again and it won’t do it again.

Em: [laughs]

Rach: Yeah.

Jeri: And you’re like, “I swear it wasn’t me.”

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Wait. But except– Jeri, except, Jeri, this time–

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Em: [laughs] Like begging for people to be on his side about it, yeah.

Christine: Okay.

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: But this time, you did– he did fart. He just won’t admit it. Like he–

Rach: Yes.

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: –not really, but like he did have the experience, and he’s like, “No, I’ll prove it.” And so he’s trying extra hard to compensate, you know?

Jeri: He did fart.

Christine: Like he clearly knows something’s up. He did fart this time. I know it for sure.

Jeri: He did fart.

Em: For sure.

Jeri: That’s funny.

Rach: Okay. “Number two. This one is legitimately scary.” Great. Love it.

Christine: [chuckles]

Rach: “One weekend in 2022, we spent the weekend at an Airbnb in Warwick, New Y– New York to visit some wineries there. That first night, I could not shake the feeling of being watched. We went to sleep, and I unfortunately experienced sleep paralysis.”

Christine: Mm-mmm.

Rach: “I was very aware that something was in the room with us, but could not move my limbs to warn Z. He sleeps like a Victorian child–“

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: “–so if anyone were to break in, he’d drool through it.”

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: “As I’m–“

Jeri: Ah, are they historically good sleepers?

Rach: Victorian–

Christine: I don’t know. But I love it. I’m like–

Em: Usually, they’re just like–

Jeri: I just thought they were historically sick.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Yeah.

Em: They’re historically kind of almost already dead, so.

Christine: Sickly.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: [chuckles]

Christine: Yeah. Yeah, close to the veil.

Rach: “As I’m fighting with my mind to awaken my limbs, my eyes are tracking movement I cannot see, but feel. I’m concentrating so hard, I start to see the shape of a young woman.”

Christine: Ooh.

Rach: “I have the immediate thought that she died here, that her body is nearby, and we should be wary of our host.”

Christine: Yeesh.

Rach: “All at once, my feeling comes back, and I shoot up in bed. Movement seemed to startle her, and she shot across the room, [pauses] climbed atop the dresser–“

Jeri: [gasps]

Christine: Ah!

Rach: “–and into the closed vent–“

Christine: [laughs] Ah!

Em: What now?

Rach: “–I did not notice was on my side of the room.”

Christine: No!

Em: I was wondering why you paused–

Christine: Yeah, I did too.

Em: –and I was like, “What’s going on here?”

Christine: I thought there was a lag, but oh my god.

Rach: I’m not liking it.

Jeri: She’s like, “I– Hey, I’d like to not read any more.” [laughs]

Christine: No.

Rach: “A vent that connected–“

Christine: Sorry we gave you the worst one.

Rach: “–the rental to the main house–“

Jeri: [gasps]

Rach: “–where our host was currently staying.”

Christine: Shut the fuck up.

Rach: “I sobbed in fear–“

Jeri: I want to crawl out of my skin right now.

Christine: That’s, that’s like–

Jeri: Like I don’t feel– I don’t wanna be here. [chuckles]

Christine: This is a mo– This is a movie script. This is heinous.

Em: [sighs]

Rach: “I sobbed in fear and turned on all the lights, roughly shaking Z awake. He tried to comfort me, saying it was just a nightmare, but she knocked off my bracelets and engagement ring I left on the trinket tray–“

Jeri: [gasps]

Rach: “–in the center of the dresser–“

Christine: Agh!

Rach: “–and they were lying on the floor.”

Em: Oh my god.

Christine: Fuck off.

Rach: “I could not speak for the rest of the night ’cause every time I would get comfortable, I would stare at the vent, and it felt like she was just outside my view, watching me back. Ew, ew, ew, ew, ew, ew, ew.”

Em: Oh my god.

Christine: From the vent? Oh my god.

Rach: “I don’t even like writing this. [gibberish keysmash sounds]”

Em: Yeah, agreed.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Is that what it says? That’s fucking– I mean, wow.

Rach: “Z maintains–“

Em: So that’s the worse, certainly.

Rach: “–that I just had a nightmare and that my jewelry must have slid off themselves.”

Jeri: Z, I’ve– Honestly–

Rach: I’ve had enough of you.

Jeri: –I’ve had enough.

Christine: I’ve had it. I’ve had it.

Em: In that moment, divorce. I would be like, “You have to be–“ I would– I can’t–

Christine: I’m out.

Jeri: I’ll send you– Hey.

Em: I need you to be on my side.

Jeri: I’ll send you my lawyer’s information.

Rach: Right, right.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Li–

Jeri: That’s my s– [chuckles] That’s my advice.

Christine: I mean–

Rach: “How he didn’t even hear that racket was beyond me. But men, I guess.”

Christine: [sighs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: At a certain point.

Rach: “Number three.”

Jeri: There's a third?

Rach: This is the last one. There’s a third one–

Christine: There’s another one?

Em: I really– I’m t– I don’t wanna do it anymore actually, so.

Rach: –titled, “We still have beef about this.”

Em: Duh.

Jeri: What’s upse– The reason I don’t want you to keep going is because I feel like I– if I’m writing this, I would have saved the worst for last–

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –and that second one–

Em: I agree.

Christine: That’s what I’m– That’s exactly right.

Jeri: –was really bad. [chuckles]

Christine: It can’t get o–

Em: I agree.

Christine: It can’t go on. We can’t go on.

Rach: I think she’s going in order of, of time.

Jeri: Oh, of events. Okay. Chronological.

Rach: Yeah, chronological.

Jeri: Got it. Okay. Cool.

Em: Let’s hope. Okay.

Rach: “The last experience was maybe a year or two ago. Our apartment is directly in between two cemeteries, and one night I saw the shape of a man standing at the foot of our bed.”

Christine: Oh my god.

Rach: “Z is already asleep, and I was just settling in for the night. I saw the shape.” Oh. “I screamed. I’m shaking Z and screaming, not once breaking my gaze from what I assumed at the time was just a random man in our room.”

Christine: [gasps]

Rach: “Z was stirring. ‘There’s a man? Where?’ While he’s slowly putting on his glasses, mind you. By the time he’s up, the shadow man disappears, and I smack Z with my pillow.”

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: “If there had been a person there, we would have–“

Christine: Exactly.

Em: Yeah.

Rach: [chuckles] “–we would have been goners.”

Em: Yeah.

Rach: “Luckily, it was just a ghost. But it pissed me off so much that it–“

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: “–it just stood there, watching us, stayed as Z was waking up, and then peaced out before he could actually get his eyes on it.”

Christine: [groans]

Rach: “I yell at him about this frequently, LOL. Thank you so much for taking the–”

Christine: Quit it, Suzy.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: “Thank you, thank you so much for taking the time to read the frustrating accounts of my husband’s disbelief. I’ll be sure to update y’all if that ever changes. Thanks for the laughs and scares. Much love, Kristina.”

Christine: It sure better.

Em: I don’t know who I’m more mad at, the husband or the ghost, ’cause it’s like both of them are working together to make sure that I cannot be proven.

Rach: They’re in cahoots.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: To gaslight you, to gaslight you.

Em: Yeah, I’m over it.

Rach: They’re gaslighting you–

Jeri: Yep.

Christine: They’re like gaslighting Kristina.

Jeri: That email felt like a shit sandwich.

Rach: Mm.

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: It felt like the bad was right in the middle. [chuckles]

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Yeah. That–

Jeri: Like it was bookended by something I could tolerate.

Rach: A young woman scurrying up your walls into a vent?

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: That would–

Jeri: [sighs]

Christine: Bye.

Em: Scurrying. The scurrying, all the time.

Rach: Enough is enough,

Christine: And then, and then–

Rach: Enough is enough.

Christine: And climbing onto the dresser like a little spider person? Like I don’t think so. And the fact that like, “Oh, maybe it was a nightmare. I do wanna believe my skeptic husband. Oh, why is my engagement ring on the floor with my jewelry?”

Jeri: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Christine: I mean, no.

Em: No. I beg to differ.

Jeri: Your Honor, explain that.

Christine: Yeah.

Em: Yeah. [chuckles]

Christine: We all rest our case.

Jeri: Explain that.

Rach: Explain that.

Em: Oof.

Jeri: The reason–

Em: I–

Jeri: Okay, so that was horrifying. I experienced a sleep paralysis situation where I– my son was in the other room. My husband at the time had left to go to work, and I heard what I thought was him coming back in like he had forgotten something.

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: And so I heard his keys, and then I open my eyes, and I see a woman in my doorway, and it was an old woman.

Christine: My god.

Em: [sighs]

Jeri: So– Which is what I was picturing whenever you were–

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: –reading this.

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: And she looked at me, just turned her head, and walked out. Now, I have the baby monitor–

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: –on my bedside table. I see her walk in on the baby monitor–

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: –to my son’s room.

Em: I– You are fucking lying.

Christine: [gasps] [laughs]

Jeri: I am like crying because I want t– but she was very– Like I could hear my son crying, and I wanted to get up desperately and I couldn’t and– But in that situation, she was at least trying to like tend to my kid.

Rach: Right.

Jeri: She wasn’t scurrying up my dresser into a vent.

Rach: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Oh my god.

Em: Honestly, I– Thi– I– This is why I know I sh– can’t– I’m sorry. I’m watching two lizards. It’s mating season, and they’re on my wall. It’s crazy.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Oh, wow.

Em: They– They’re going for it.

Christine: That’s pornographic.

Em: Um, I–

Jeri: These stories get me all hot and bothered too. [laughs]

Rach: Hot and bothered.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: I, um, I feel like, in that moment, there’s a reason why I’m not meant to be a parent because if I saw a, a woman approaching my, my kid’s crib and–

Jeri: Uh-huh?

Em: –in my mind, I’m sorry, I’m thinking of the scurrying woman, I’d be like, “I don’t– I can’t get in there. I wouldn’t–“

Rach: You’re on your own, kid.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: You’re on your own.

Em: You’re on your own. Learn to fight. I don’t know what–

Jeri: Yep.

Em: I wouldn’t know what to do. [chuckles] It would horrify me.

Christine: Wow.

Jeri: It’s like when you throw them into a pool and you hope that they flip over. [laughs]

Rach: Right.

Em: Like sometimes it’s for the greater good.

Jeri: Like, “Hey, I can’t do anything for you right now.” [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Just like that. Um, I was gonna say too– I’m sorry. I’m still stuck on– I mean, aren’t we all? This woman scurrying.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Okay. And also, I wanna add too like the fact that the vent connects to the main house is so distressing to me. It’s like–

Em: Yeah.

Christine: –clearly something in my mind, my– It’s like something was coming to watch you like in your guest room.

Rach: And also–

Jeri: For sure.

Rach: –in this situation, as someone who knows virtually nothing about the paranormal, are we assuming this wasn’t a ghost? It was some sort of like–

Christine: I don’t know.

Rach: Do ghosts scurry?

Christine: I’m assuming it wasn’t a ghost.

Rach: You know what I mean?

Em: It could have–

Christine: I’m assuming it was like some sort of like entity, like negative entity. I don’t know. Yeah.

Em: Also, I mean– I– It would cross my mind for a moment like was this like the people in the main house that were like–

Jeri: Yes.

Em: –like a true crime appear–

Jeri: Yes.

Em: –like they’re phrogging or living in the ceiling or something–

Jeri: That’s what I thought too because–

Em: –and got busted?

Christine: They’re like–

Jeri: What was that one movie–

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: –where the grandparents–

Em: The Watcher house? Oh.

Jeri: The grandparents were not really the grandparents–

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: –and they were like under the house, and they were like cli-climb in the oven to clean it or whatever.

Em: Yes.

Christine: What in the fuck?

Jeri: That's what it reminded me of.

Christine: I don’t want to watch that. I don’t know what that is. I’m with Rachel on this. I don’t even know what Rachel thinks, but I’m with her because this sounds terrible.

Em: I know what you’re talking about. I–

Rach: I think I’ve seen clips of this where they like get on FaceTime with their mom–

Jeri: Yes.

Em: Yeah.

Rach: –and they’re like, “That’s not your grandparents.”

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: Hey. Bye.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Stop.

Rach: And I’ve always wondered–

Christine: Everybody stop.

Rach: –who dropped them off? You know? Who dropped them off there then?

Christine: I’m gonna hang up on all of you in five seconds.

Em: It was a bad movie. Um, but I–

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: –I mean, I would have at least– certainly it– ’Cause Christine and I are always talking about like which is– when you hear a sound in the middle of the night like–

Jeri: Right.

Em: –do you hope it’s a ghost or do you hope it’s a–

Christine: True crime? Ghost?

Em: –s-someone’s breaking in?

Jeri: Right.

Em: Um, and, uh, I– if I woke up and saw someone near my jewelry while I’m sleeping in a guest house, I, I would think someone broke in and is trying to rob me.

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Em: And then all of a sudden, they scurry into the wall, and I’d be like, “What the fuck was that?”

Christine: Oh no. Yeah.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Rach: I’m sorry. I’m picking up. I’m picking up and moving.

Jeri: No, I’m not staying there.

Christine: I’m leaving.

Em: Yeah, I’m gone.

Rach: When, when things got bad with Elsie, I– we had only been in the house for like four months, and I was like, “We have to move.”

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: We have to move.

Jeri: But you didn’t.

Rach: No, we didn’t.

Christine: Yeah. I mean, how, how could you–

Em: Yeah, yeah. Totally.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: It’s like–

Rach: No, I got [unintelligible]. I said, “Grow up.”

Christine: And thank god they were just staying at this place instead of like–

Em: [laughs]

Christine: –living there. I don’t know. Wow.

Em: I, uh– Yeah. Yikes.

Christine: Um, but I will say I had never thought about it this way, but I think Blaise also sleeps like a Victorian child, if that’s what we’re going with.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: Because I do sometimes hear– Like the other day, there was a crash in– Well, it wasn’t the other day. It was a few weeks ago. There was a crash in– on the third floor of my house, and I assumed like the cat had broken a glass. Like I heard glass shattering, and like you don’t wanna hear glass shattering in the middle of the night. And I literally turned to my husband, who is like a martial arts person and like trains every day, has a baseball bat in the bed. I’m like, “Wake up,” and he’s like, “No, I’m tired.” And I’m like, “There– Something– Some glass shattered,” and he said, “Oh, that’s too bad.” And I’m like, “Will you get the–“

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: Activate, brother.

Jeri: “That sounds like a later me problem.”

Christine: Like he’s like act– He’s not activating.

Rach: Activate.

Christine: And it took me–

Em: Like where’s your sleeper agent button? It’s time to kick in.

Christine: I really– I– and then I said–

Jeri: Yeah. [laughs]

Christine: And then I try– I said– I’ll, I’ll do the big– I’ll do the big, the big show– the big finale. I said, “I think someone’s in the house,” and he goes, “I’m sure–“ He’s like, “Oh? What? I don’t think so.” And I’m like, “Okay. So nothing apparently– I need–“

Rach: Bitch, I am hearing it.

Christine: So–

Em: I feel like the first, the first thing–

Christine: Yeah, so totally out of commission.

Em: If you’re gonna be a martial arts person, I feel like the first thing you– the first step is wake up.

Christine: Hypervi-vigilance.

Em: But I feel like– You know, they, they teach you– Well, I don’t, I don’t know for sure, but I imagine they teach you like how to remain calm in situations. And he’s like too calm.

Christine: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Em: I’m like, “You gotta–“

Jeri: He’s too good at that part.

Em: “It’s time to begin what you’ve been training for. Let’s go.”

Christine: I mean, thank god, by the way, as Em and I always discuss, like you just said, it was a ghost. ’Cause the glass panel of my vanity up here just like flung itself off and shattered everywhere. It’s also a mirror, which felt like bad luck. Um, but yeah, it was weird. And the fact that Blaise didn’t wake up, I almost was like, “Uh-oh, now the ghosts know he’s not gonna get up anytime soon.” [chuckles]

Jeri: Not helpful at all.

Em: Yeah, it’s like all that training is for naught.

Rach: No. [unintelligible] Josh all the time.

Christine: Totally.

Rach: Josh, once he’s asleep, once he’s act– he’s dead.

Jeri: Useless.

Rach: He’s gone. He’s sleep-Josh. He’s useless.

Christine: Like they’re, they’re gone. Where are you?

Rach: He’s terrible. He’s a horrible husband, terrible father.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Victorian child.

Rach: He’s like– He literally–

Christine: [laughs] He’s a Victorian child near the death– near death.

Rach: He’s n– He’s no use.

Christine: [sighs]

Em: Allison and I, I–

Christine: Terrible.

Em: We regularly say that I look more like the boy, but I act like the girl, and she looks like the girl, but acts like the boy.

Jeri: [laughs]

Em: And she really also sleeps like a Victorian child. [chuckles]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: And like I know if someone broke in with a, with an axe, stabbed me a million times–

Christine: Yeah.

Em: –where I had time to scream for an hour – and we live in a shoe box – she would just sleep the whole way through.

Rach: Okay.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: She would roll over and go, “Are you okay?” and then like roll back over. Like that’s how Blaise is too.

Em: Yeah. She–

Rach: Yeah. If Josh is in deep sleep, kiss, kiss it goodbye.

Christine: Forget it.

Rach: [unintelligible]

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: We’re gone.

Em: But it’s just one of those things where I’m like, “Ugh, you are the man, aren’t you, Allison?” [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Ugh. Such a, such a guy. And then, “I, I’m sure it was just a nightmare,” you know.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Like ugh.

Em: Oh god.

Christine: Ugh.

Jeri: Well, you know who needs to train Blaise is Leona.

Christine: Apparently.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: ’Cause she’s sleeping with her eyes open.

Christine: [laughs] She’s–

Jeri: He could take a couple lessons.

Rach: Right.

Christine: I’m gonna get her a baseball bat to put by her bed. [laughs]

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs] That’s who needs that bat.

Christine: Yeah, the one with the eyes wide open all night long. Um, okay. Wow, that was a doozy. Uh, is it–

Em: Man.

Christine: Is it my– Are there, are there more? Is it my turn? What’s happening?

Em: Uh, there’s two more. Yeah. So–

Christine: I feel like I’ve left the planet again. Sorry.

[glass clinks - start of ad break]

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[straw sucking bottom of glass - end of ad break]

Story 5 – The Woman in the Laundry Room Wasn't My Mom... And Now My Dad Has Some New Beliefs

Em: This one, this one is from Cait, who uses she/her pronouns. Thank you for normalizing pronouns. And the subject line is, “Hey, the woman in the laundry room wasn’t my mom… and now my dad has some new beliefs.”

Christine: Aw. “Hello everyone. Thanks so much to Eva.” That should, that should be how every email starts.

Rach: Thank you, Eva.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: “Thanks–“ [laughs] But thanks to Eva for making today possible, for making every day possible.

Em: Of course.

Christine: “Thanks so much to Eva for reading my story. I appreciate all the hard work you do. Also if Christine and Em are reading this–“ Ah! Okay. Love that.

Em: [chuckles]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Uh, “Thanks for all the laughs. I’ve been listening since episode 25.” Oh my gosh.

Jeri: Oh, wow.

Em: Wow. Long time listener.

Christine: “Be–“ That is a long time. “Be aware, there is a slight trigger warning for a mention of suicide for this story.”

Em: Okay.

Christine: Okay, let’s crack into it. “As you can tell by the title, my dad has some new beliefs about what the afterlife could look like.” So does Blaise apparently.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: He went to a Tyler Henry show–

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: –at the Hard Rock Casino, and it changed his view on life, I guess.

Em: You never know what it’s gonna be.

Christine: You never know what it takes, you know. Uh, okay. [looking for where she left] Ba-duh-ba-duh-ba. “As you can tell by the title, my dad has some new beliefs about what the afterlife could look like, and it all started with the woman in the laundry room. The following stories and family lore has been told to me by my mother, who swears these were the experiences my– that made my dad realize maybe there is actually something to look forward to after our time here on Earth. Also, bear with me. There are two stories, but you can’t tell one without the other, so here I go. For a quick bit of context, my grandparents and great-uncles are all from the Appalachian Mountain area. When my great-uncle was in his early 20s, he was dating a girl we’ll call Jamie. Jamie was so madly in love with my uncle that when he decided he was moving to California to start over, she was coming with him.”

Em: Hm.

Christine: “My uncle, however, told Jamie she could come with him, but he would not marry her (for what reason, I have no idea).” I mean, I mean, maybe she just– he just didn’t want to. I don’t know.

Em: Yeah, right. Yeah. [chuckles]

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: Sure. Free will and all that.

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: Could be anything.

Christine: Like I guess that’s allowed, I think. “She came with him anyways and once– when months later he broke up with her–“ Yeah. “–she showed up at my grandparents’ house in a wedding–“ Oh god. Okay.

Rach: Oh?

Christine: Sorry. This gets really, really dark. Okay. Sorry. Whoa. I did not see this coming. Okay. Uh, “She came with him anyways, and when months later, he broke up with her, she showed up at my grandparents’ house in a wedding dress and died by suicide in front of them.”

Jeri: [gasps]

Em: Oh my god.

Rach: What the hell?

Jeri: Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.

Em: Oh my god.

Rach: In front of him or just his parents?

Christine: In front of the grandparents. Like so his parents.

Em: Oh my fucking god.

Jeri: Wow.

Christine: “Everyone in my family has known about this since, since, including my dad, even though he was not alive when the events took place.” So this was like her grandpa.

Em: Mm.

Rach: Okay.

Christine: Um, oh my god. What the fuck?

Jeri: Horrifying story. Horrible.

Em: Jesus.

Christine: And then it says, “End of trigger warning.” [chuckles]

Em: Thanks.

Jeri: Thanks.

Christine: So that’s good. [chuckles]

Em: Thank you so much.

Rach: Trigger over.

Christine: Thank you.

Jeri: Hey, I got that. [chuckles]

Christine: Hey, I think we– Yeah.

Em: [chuckles] Yeah, we figured that one out. Yeah.

Jeri: We couldn’t imagine there was more after. [chuckles]

Em: Yeah.

Christine: We all landed on the other side and went, “What the fuck?”

Em: Jesus. Okay.

Jeri: Whoa.

Christine: All right. “End of trigger warning. Other added context. My dad prior to these events was the biggest skeptic my mom knew as he would make fun of her even talking about supernatural things. When my mom and dad were 20 years old, my dad was in the military. After long deployments, my parents would come home to a small farm town in the middle of California to see their families. On one of these trips home while visiting my dad’s parents, he saw something he’d never forget and still refuses to speak about to this day. It was an easy day of lounging around and talking to my grandma about baby shower plans when my dad decided he’d do the laundry for him and my mom before they packed up to go to his cousin’s house.” See, first man who’s just stepping up and doing the laundry.

Rach: Really.

Christine: Thank you.

Rach: Incredible.

Christine: Incredible.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: Uh, okay. “It was an easy day of lounging around, talking to my grandma about ba– about baby shower plans when my dad decided he’d do the laundry before they packed up to go to his cousin’s house. Think of an old home that was built in the ‘90s where you walk in the garage and then straight ahead through the living room was the kitchen. My dad walked down the long hallway to the garage where the washer and dryer were located. While switching the clothes from the washer to the dryer, my dad saw something white and flowy out of the corner of his eye.”

Jeri: Oh no.

Christine: Oh my god. “When he looked up, he saw–“ Wait, hold on. Wasn’t that also what that lady was wearing in the yard?

Em: Sh–

Christine: Like nose to nose with that guy?

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: Oh, yeah.

Jeri: Yep, the bride.

Christine: Oh god. Oh my god. The bride on the wedding day.

Em: Unfortunately, in this case– Yeah, she also looks like the–

Christine: Jeez.

Em: –bride.

Christine: Oh, that’s right. Yeah. Okay. Here we go. “While switching the clothes from the washer to the dryer, my dad saw something white and flowy out of the corner of his eye. When he looked up, he saw the back of a woman with long dark hair walking through the garage door into the house wearing a long white dress.” Oh my god. “He called for my mom. But before he could get an answer, the door slammed shut. My mom told me that my dad explained after seeing this woman, he felt an immense amount of dread. And with that, he took off running down the hallway. When he got into the living room, he found my mom and grandma talking. There, he interrogated my mom and grandma, demanding to know who came down the hallway and why they were trying to scare him. When they swore up and down that neither of them had done it and that he was the only one in and out of the garage, all the color drained from his face. In the same trip home just days later, my mom and dad went to stay with his cousins, the children of the earlier mentioned uncle, and visit just before heading back to San Diego. One night after going to sleep, my dad awoke to the sound of knocking on the sliding glass door–” Oh my god.

Jeri: No. No.

Christine: “–that was across the living room from the air mattress he and my mom were sleeping on. He sat up, and when he turned to look at the sliding glass door, he saw the same woman he had seen a few days ago–”

Em: Oh my god.

Christine: “–clawing and pulling at the sliding glass door.”

Rach: No. No, no, no, no.

Jeri: Clawing?

Em: Clawing?

Rach: Not clawing.

Jeri: Claw– Hey. Hey, ghost. Stop clawing.

Em: [sighs]

Jeri: Stop climbing. Stop. Stop doing those things.

Christine: Quit it, S–

Em: The scur– The scurrying and the clawing–

Christine: Quit it, Suzy.

Em: The, the animal movements–

Rach: Scurrying.

Em: –is too much.

Christine: It’s, it’s–

Jeri: It must be done.

Christine: What it, what it is is untenable, frankly.

Em: Thank you.

Rach: Untenable.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: It is. It’s untenable. And I’m just gonna–

Jeri: [unintelligible] incredible word.

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: My new, my new hex is “Quit it, Suzy,” and that should just calm it all. Like just everything–

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: –gotta stop, you know.

Jeri: [chuckles]

Christine: Quit it, Suzy.

Em: Absolutely.

Christine: That’s enough, Suzy. Okay. Um, “–clawing–“ Blegh. “–and pulling at the sliding glass door. She made eye contact with him–“

Rach: [gasps]

Jeri: No.

Christine: “–and put her hand against the glass of the door–“

Em: What?

Christine: “–as, as she faded away.” [chuckles] Jesus.

Em: What kind of fucking Steven Spielberg E.T. shit was that?

Christine: I know.

Em: What do you mean?

Christine: It’s so spooky.

Em: Ugh.

Jeri: Do you think that her dad looked like her uncle?

Christine: Ohh.

Em: Ohh. Yep.

Jeri: And then the woman was like, “There you are, you motherfucker. I found you.”

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: “I’ve been looking for your ass–” [chuckles]

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: “–for eternity.”

Em: Absolutely.

Christine: You know, you just gave me full fucking chills because– especially at that age 20, which is like–

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: –the same age around when this would have ha– Oh my god, Jeri.

Jeri: [unintelligible]

Rach: Well, and also–

Em: God. [sighs]

Rach: –where did she commit suicide?

Christine: At the grandparents’ house.

Em: At there.

Rach: At– that was built in the ‘90s?

Christine: No, no, no. That was in Appalachia. So–

Em: Oh, oh, oh.

Rach: Ohh, and they were in California.

Christine: So now they’re like the whole f–

Rach: And then she–

Christine: They’ve all moved to California. But also she followed him to California, remember? Like back to–

Jeri: That’s true.

Em: Yeah. She could have been attached to like something that was still in the house or something and just gone with them or been attached to them. Shit. I don’t know.

Rach: Oh.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: That’s horrifying.

Rach: [unintelligible]

Christine: Oh my god.

Em: Ugh.

Jeri: Yeah. Especially like dying in such a traumatic way.

Christine: Yes. Yeah.

Jeri: Like I could also see it being something that like she relives constantly.

Christine: She’s just like in this weird lim-limbo space. Yeah. Yeah.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: I, I wonder– the– If this were a Steven Spielberg E.T. movie, I feel like they have like now like found common ground with the hand up on the glass together. [chuckles] And I feel like maybe now she’ll go the fuck away, you know?

Jeri: Maybe.

Christine: Uhh, maybe.

Em: I’m– That’s what I’m hoping.

Christine: [chuckles]

Em: I’m like, let’s have a happy ending here.

Christine: That feels– I feel like Steven Spielberg would be like–

Em: Like, “Oh, now we’ve made contact through the glass. Like, let’s agree to disagree and walk away.”

Jeri: It’s giving your TV master’s. That’s what’s happening right now.

Christine: [chuckles]

Em: Thank you. You know, well earned.

Jeri: [unintelligible] [laughs]

Christine: Is, is that what’s happening? Yeah. Okay. Yeah, yeah, the– Okay, I see. Okay. [looking for where she left off] Buh-buh-buh. So he saw this woman at the sliding glass door. She made eye contact, put her hand against the glass, and faded away. “My dad went back to sleep (I don’t know how he managed that) and had countless night terrors, uh, of him waking up to find the woman standing over him.” Oh god, she got in.

Rach: Like, come on.

Christine: Uh–

Em: Never mind. Uh, you gotta rip up my degree now.

Christine: I know. Em, I was like, “Steven Spielberg would just– I don’t think he would end things so–“

Em: It’s become Stephen King.

Jeri: All of a sudden, a velociraptor’s there for some reason.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs] “My dad went back to sleep–“ Uh–

Rach: Climb in through the window.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs] “He had countless night terrors, all of this woman standing, uh, standing over him, staring with her hurt and sorrowful brown eyes into his. My dad told my mom all of this, and after looking at the sliding glass door she was trying to get through, he realized there was still a handprint.”

Jeri: No, no, no.

Christine: Hm. Yikes.

Em: It’s in that moment. I would literally buy a–

Rach: Goodbye.

Em: –fingerprint kit o-or something just to have evidence of this.

Christine: [gasps] A fingerprint kit.

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: You and I would be on Amazon like–

Rach: [unintelligible]

Jeri: “Who’s this belong to?”

Christine: –“Hold on. This is a crime scene.”

Em: I need, I need to show people like, “This bitch was here. Here’s her literal DNA.”

Christine: Yes, she felt–

Jeri: Your Honor?

Christine: Your Honor? [laughs]

Em: Your Honor, get it together.

Christine: I present to the court.

Em: Get real.

Christine: [laughs] What do you call it–

Jeri: You just keep one of those glass cutters in like– like they do in the spy movies–

Christine: Oh, the circle thing?

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: –cut around it?

Christine: From Spy Kids or whatever? Yeah. No joke.

Jeri: I’m assuming that’s a real thing.

Rach: Yeah. Oh, for sure.

Christine: Also, I feel like– I mean, this is just– Okay, it’s all just very horrible. Okay. Uh, so, “My dad told my mom, and he realized there was still a handprint.” Uh, uh-huh. “To this day, that handprint is still on the sliding glass door.” Em, get your kit. Get your fingerprint kit.

Em: Literally, it– Like today is the day.

Rach: [unintelligible] talking about?

Christine: Um–

Rach: They can’t get it off?

Christine: Um, hey, Cait, can you just get a fingerprint kit over there now? Stat.

Em: Like stat. Yes.

Christine: Pronto.

Jeri: Get a new door.

Em: What are you, what are you, what are you an idiot?

Christine: Get a new door.

Em: [in a New York gangster accent] Come on. We gotta do th– Like–

Jeri: [laughs] [in a New York gangster accent] Come on. Hey, hey!

Em: –do it now.

Rach: [in a New York gangster accent] Hey! Think about it! Think about it.

Christine: Amateur hour.

Em: One and one is two. Let’s go.

Jeri: [in a New York gangster accent] Keep your paws off the door.

Christine: This is–

Jeri: [in a New York gangster accent] What are you, an animal?

Em: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: Also, like, has anyone tried to wipe that off? ’Cause that feels like you’re desecrating–

Christine: Well, yeah, I would im–

Em: –re– bodily remains or something. It feels weird to–

Rach: Oh, I’d take Windex to it.

Christine: Oh, really? I would–

Jeri: Oh, yeah.

Christine: I was gonna say I’d take one of those power cleaner things. What are those?

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Those power washers.

Em: I would literally put a Sharpie border around it and be like–

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Em: –“You can wash the window, but not this section ’cause this is the only–“

Jeri: I’d turn it into a turkey so fast. [laughs]

Em: This is– [laughs]

Christine: [laughs] A turkey.

Em: This is one of those things where I’d be like, if there, if there’s ever a contest where it’s like, “We’re looking for literal evidence of a ghost,” you have it right there.

Christine: Dear lord.

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: Okay, wow.

Em: That's a money maker. That’s a money maker.

Christine: I mean, I just can’t.

Jeri: Great. I turned it into a turkey. There goes the money. [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: How do you turn it into a turkey?

Christine: Oh, man.

Jeri: You’ve never made a turkey hand?

Rach: Oh, I see what you mean.

Jeri: Okay. [laughs]

Rach: Wasn’t following.

Christine: Oh, I see what you mean.

Rach: I wasn’t following at all.

Em: I, I’m with you.

Christine: Okay. Okay, okay.

Rach: [laughs] It’s funny. Now that I understand what you’re talking about.

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: Like that was a good joke.

Christine: [laughs] Oh god. Okay. Uh, yeah. Now, how do we get back into this terrible sad tragic story? Let’s see. “To this day, the handprint is still on that sliding glass door. It’s believed the print–“ [gasps] Okay.

Em: Tell me.

Christine: Now this is even getting spookier. I mean, I didn’t think it could.

Em: Tell me immediately. What?

Christine: “It’s believed the print is between the two panes of glass and that is why nobody can scrub it off.”

Em: Okay, but she preserved herself. She fucking knows it’s a money maker.

Christine: I know. That’s fucking amazing.

Rach: Here’s the money maker.

Christine: ’Cause she was trying to go through the glass. Holy shit.

Jeri: She said, “It’s a fossil.”

Em: And by the way, with an Expo marker, you can make as many turkeys as you want now.

Jeri: [laughs] Yeah.

Christine: ’Cause it’s a permanent fixture.

Em: We all win.

Jeri: Yeah.

Em: We all win.

Christine: Oh my god. “So my dad–“

Rach: And she has not been seen since?

Christine: “My dad told my mo–“ Uh, okay, the sliding glass door. “It’s believed the print is between the two panes of glass and that is why nothing can clean it off. My dad at that point told my mom he believed in the afterlife now because how could you not when your uncle’s dead ex-girlfriend won’t quit following you around and made her promise not to tell anyone.”

Em: Mm.

Christine: “So yeah, that’s how my uncle’s ex-girlfriend was the woman in the laundry room that was not my mom and made my skeptic dad believe in ghosts. And that’s why he drinks.” Oh my word.

Jeri: And that’s why he drinks. [laughs]

Christine: First of all, I’m very, I’m very sorry also for the family trauma, and I’m not–

Em: Right.

Christine: –we’re not trying to laugh through that.

Em: We’re just glazing past that.

Christine: It’s– ’Cause that part is just absolutely bananas level like–

Jeri: Yes.

Christine: –not okay. But just like the fact that your dad is just like going about his life, never having even met this person, and then all of a sudden–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: –she’s like, “You look just like him.” Like that’s fucking terrifying.

Em: Horrifying.

Rach: And he was young when this happened? Is that like it was him as a young–

Jeri: The uncle was, yes.

Christine: Yeah. He was really young. He like moved away from home.

Rach: The uncle was young, but how old was her dad when–

Jeri: The– He wasn’t alive.

Rach: No, I, I know when this happened to him.

Christine: Oh, 20. 20.

Jeri: About the same age, right?

Christine: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Rach: Oh, okay.

Christine: Like 20, so they were–

Jeri: He was about the same age the uncle was when she–

Rach: Crazy.

Jeri: –completed suicide.

Christine: Yes.

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Which I think makes so much sense to Jeri’s point of they probably resemble one another pretty strongly–

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: –would be my guess.

Em: Mm.

Jeri: Just like, “There you are, you handsome motherfather”.

Rach: Mm-mmm.

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: “Yeah, I’m gonna come in that door.”

Jeri: He said, “Up top!” [holds hand up for a high five]

Christine: Oh, so spooky!

Jeri: And now my– [chuckles] Now it’s on your glass forever.

Christine: I know. Wow. That’s just like– That’s like a– That’s a good one. That’s a really good one.

Em: All right, we have one left. Who would like to read it?

Rach: Who wants to take us home? Jeri, you wanna–

Christine: Jeri.

Jeri: Do you want me to take [unintelligible]?

Em: Take us home.

Jeri: “Lahl.” [as she’s adjusting in her chair and moving the computer over]

Em: All right.

Rach: [unintelligible]

Christine: I’m gonna actually call my mom to take me home ’cause I am a little scared.

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: “Mom, pick me up. I’m scared.”

Christine: “Mom, [pretending to cry] pick me up.”

[glass clinks - start of ad break]

[Rotating ads vary, for a full list of current podcast sponsors visit andthatswhywedrink.com/sponsors]

[straw sucking bottom of glass - end of ad break]

Story 6 – The Time I Asked My Sister-in-law's Dead Dad to Grab My Skeptic Boyfriend's Ass

Jeri: This is “The time I asked my sister-in-law’s dead dad to grab my skeptic boyfriend’s ass.”

Christine: [gasps]

Em: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: Incredible already.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Wow.

Jeri: No notes. [chuckles]

Em: I’m fine with that so far. Yeah.

Jeri: Although consent’s important. I’m just saying that.

Christine: I was about to say. I feel like maybe I should be the voice of reason here, but maybe I won’t be.

Jeri: Yeah. We’ll–

Em: I think I’m a little, um– I’m putting my own experience in, uh, in the loop when I make that statement because I have been – we were saying “polter-groped.”

Christine: Right, that’s true.

Em: I’ve been grabbed on the ass by a ghost. And because the story is good, I’m fine with it.

Christine: It is a good–

Jeri: [unintelligible]

Rach: [unintelligible]

Em: So I think like in hindsight.

Christine: Do it for the bit. Yeah.

Jeri: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Yeah, yeah. For sure.

Em: Seems like in hindsight, I would hope that this, this– we’re–

Christine: All in good fun.

Em: For the story.

Christine: All in good fun.

Rach: They did it for the bit. They did it for the bit.

Em: Yeah, yeah.

Christine: Did it for the bit big time.

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: “Hello, Em and Christine. I saw the call for skeptical partner stories and ran to the submission page. I can’t remember a time in my life when I didn’t have some sense of the paranormal world. I remember being three and telling my mom I didn’t like the ghosts in my room.” Valid.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: Yeah. Who would?

Jeri: Off the jump, valid.

Christine: Who would?

Jeri: “To which she told me, at three, ‘They just need my help.’ So thanks for the complex, Mom.” [laughs]

Christine: Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Yeah. No, no, no, no. [laughs]

Rach: Can you imagine?

Em: I’m good.

Jeri: “Oh, they’re there for your assistance, three-year-old.”

Christine: It’s like, “You know how you help– you know how you therapize Mommy all day?”

Em: [laughs]

Christine: “Well, now you have to therapize these ghosts too.”

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Just kidding. That was just a joke.

Jeri: Yeah. Awesome.

Christine: That was not a reference to this person’s actual parent.

Jeri: “She would also tell me when my grandfather’s ghost was around visiting.”

Christine: Oh god.

Jeri: Cool.

Rach: [laughs]

Jeri: “So growing– [laughs] growing up–“

Christine: Nice.

Jeri: “–with this very matter-of-act interaction with spirits, I’ve become pretty used to weird things. My boyfriend, however, believes everything has an explanation.” a theme.

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: We love it. “For example, I have a Pride tiara on my shelf that I got at a local Pride parade. I’ve known since I moved into my current house that it came with an old man’s ghost, and he’s a grump.” The house or the tiara? [laughs]

Em: Yeah, wait a minute.

Christine: I thought the tiara, and I went, “An old grumpy gay?”

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: An old grumpy gay.

Christine: “What’s happening?”

Em: [laughs]

Rach: That’d be the best type of ghost to have.

Christine: I was like, “That’s a delightful spirit.” Yeah.

Em: Absolutely.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: Yeah.

Rach: A grumpy old gay?

Em: Just like a sassy curmudgeon.

Christine: Please.

Rach: [unintelligible] a sassy curmudgeon any day.

Christine: Any day.

Jeri: Listen, I do think that they mean the house–

Christine: They mean that.

Jeri: –but I like the idea that it’s attached to the tiara.

Rach: Yeah.

Em: I agree.

Christine: And also I love that like a curmudgeon had to be attached to a rainbow tiara. Like, you know, the vibe there is just–

Em: You know, he’s so fucking over it. [laughs]

Christine: –hilarious to me.

Jeri: [laughs] 100%.

Christine: It’s so good.

Jeri: Uh, “One day, my boyfriend and I were sitting minding our own business when I heard a loud ‘pling!’ sound–“

Christine: Mm.

Jeri: “–just before the tiara flew off the shelf as if someone flicked it off.”

Christine: Agh!

Jeri: “I immediately started yelling at the ghost, telling him that in my house we don’t accept that kind of shit, no matter what he believed in life.”

Em: That's right.

Jeri: Oh, got it. “After I finished, my boyfriend said, ‘I think it just fell normally.’”

Christine: Uh-huh.

Em: [chuckles] Okay. Get out.

Jeri: Hey. Hey, Kevin. Shut up.

Rach: Shut up.

Em: [laughs]

Christine: Hey, Kevin. No one asked you.

Rach: Unless there’s a cat on the loose–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Correct.

Em: Yeah.

Rach: –that you saw there.

Jeri: And as of now, I–

Christine: Correct.

Jeri: –I’ve not been told of any cats.

Em: I haven’t either.

Jeri: “This led me on a mission to find an experience my boyfriend couldn’t explain away. So I started taking him on ghost tours and hunts.” [laughs]

Christine: This is me, to a T.

Em: Good. We’re teaching.

Jeri: Take him everywhere ghosts are supposed to be.

Christine: Yeah.

Jeri: “We live in southern California, and I got tickets for a guided ghost hunt on the Queen Mary on Halloween.”

Christine: That’ll do it.

Jeri: “I told my sister-in-law that all I want is for my boyfriend to have something happen that he can’t explain and joked that it would be great if a ghost could just touch him.”

Em: Yeah.

Jeri: [chuckles] Just touch him.

Christine: [chuckles] Just a little whi– Just a little touch.

Em: So you gave consent, so–

Jeri: Uh-huh.

Rach: Yeah.

Em: –you know, it’s fine. Yeah.

Jeri: Yeah. “Her father passed away several years ago, so she called out, ‘Hey, Dad, if you can help out, touch his ass on the hunt.’” [laughs]

Christine: On the hunt?

Jeri: “Fast forward to Halloween. Some weird things happened on the hunt, but nothing that really convinced him. It went well until–“

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “–about 2 a.m.”

Em: Oh my gosh.

Jeri: “So we’d booked a room on the Queen Mary for the night.”

Rach: I’m sorry.

Jeri: I know.

Rach: These people.

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: “We get back to our room after it’s over, starting to get ready for bed, and he comes out of the bathroom, looking odd.”

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: “‘What’s up?’ I asked. Eyebrows furrowed, he says, ‘I don’t know. I was brushing my teeth, and I felt something rubbing against my ass–‘” [chuckles]

Christine: Ahh!

Jeri: “‘–but I think it was just the shower curtain.’” No, that was the grumpy gay.

Rach: That was the grumpy gay.

Em: That was the grumpy gay.

Christine: Oh, I thought it was the dad.

Jeri: It is the dad.

Rach: It is.

Jeri: It is the dad.

Christine: Oh, oh, oh, oh. It’s the grumpy gay.

Jeri: I just, I just wanna bring the grumpy gay everywhere. [chuckles]

Christine: Oh, I thought– Okay, ’cause I was like–

Jeri: He likes boats.

Christine: –“Oh my god, is the dad the grumpy gay?” Okay.

Jeri: Who, who doesn’t like boats?

Em: I don’t know.

Christine: Who doesn’t like boats?

Jeri: “I start–“

Em: And as someone– We have– We’ve, we’ve–

Christine: We’ve b–

Em: I was gonna say we’ve booked an overnight stay there. That does not mean we stayed the whole night, but we were there and can confirm the bathrooms are small, and the shower curtain could have been rubbing his butt.

Jeri: Could have rubbed him.

Em: Could have.

Jeri: Okay. Okay, that’s good–

Em: Could also be dad.

Jeri: That’s good insight. “I start laughing. He didn’t know about the conversation with my sister-in-law, and I am convinced that he couldn’t have felt the fabric shower curtain through his jeans [laughs] and her dad did in fact grab his ass in a moment of opportunity. I tell him the whole story. He’s still skeptical. I call my sister-in-law the next day. She believes that’s exactly how her dad would have done it.”

Christine: Mm-hmm.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Jeri: “We tell our friends, his co-workers, literally everyone. And every person we tell believes it had to be– it had to have been her dad. My boyfriend? To this day, he’s still not convinced. How do you get ghost-groped in a Queen Mary bathroom and still be a skeptic? I’m still dragging him on tours and hunts, and one day, I believe I’ll finally convince him. But until that day, that’s why I drink.”

Christine: Oh, wow.

Em: Love it.

Christine: Here’s what I have to say. He has to convince himself.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: He could literally see a full-blown apparition in front of his face and be like, “I was just hallucinating.” Like, there is no way you can– ’Cause I’ve tried this with Blaise.

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: And then all of a sudden, I make him take me to a Tyler Henry show and he goes, “Everything changed.” I went, “That’s what it took? I just had to show you Hollywood Medium one time?”

Em: [laughs]

Jeri: Man had to tell him.

Christine: Like I don’t know. So like I’ve taken him every ghost hunt–

Em: That's a great point.

Christine: A man had to tell him. Well, like a young– a, a gentle gay man, but still a man. Yeah. And, um, I just was very like surprised, but he’s like, “Wow, I can’t believe it.” And I’m like, “I didn’t know that was the entry point for you.”

Jeri: [laughs] “That’s all I had to do?”

Christine: But yeah, like maybe g– polter-groped wasn’t enough for this guy. But also like I just love that he, he has to know it wasn’t the shower curtain ’cause why else would he come out with a furrowed brow and go, “It must be the shower curtain.” Like if he–

Em: Right.

Christine: He would be like, “No, it was definitely the– it was–“ He wouldn’t have even told you the story.

Em: Right.

Jeri: Yeah. If he was certain that it was the shower curtain, why talk about it at all?

Christine: He wouldn’t have even brought it up.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Totally.

Jeri: Maybe, maybe he’s playing dumb, and he just likes going on these ghost tours.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: [gasps]

Jeri: So he’s like, “Oh, babe, I’m–“

Em: Maybe he’s actually having a blast.

Jeri: “I don’t believe.”

Christine: He sticks his, he sticks his butt out a little bit like–

Rach: “Keep treating me.”

Jeri: “Another one.”

Christine: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: “Keep treating me with these little, tiny, silly, little adventures.”

Christine: Oh, I just– I hur– And it’s like, “I just like when your friend’s dad just gives me a little boop, you know–“

Em: A little patty, yeah.

Jeri: Yeah.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: “–on the rear.” Yeah.

Em: [sighs]

Jeri: “It was weird ’cause the shower curtain said, ‘Good game,’ when it hit my butt.”

Christine: [laughs]

Em: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: It happens.

Jeri: “But I’m pretty sure it was the shower curtain.”

Christine: It happens. [chuckles] Good game. Oh, well, you know what? Good game to you guys too. [gives high fives to the camera]

Em: Good game. [gives high fives to the camera]

Christine: Um, we all did awesome. I am so thankful you were all here for– Sorry we to– had you for so long. Um, but that tends to happen–

Jeri: [unintelligible] time it is.

Christine: –when some yappers show up–

Jeri: Hey. To be fair–

Christine: –on a screen together.

Jeri: –we took up about 20 minutes figuring out Safari was not the move. [laughs]

Christine: Oh, yeah. [laughs]

Em: That’s okay. It happens.

Christine: Listen, it, it was all part of the journey.

Rach: My– I’m gonna have to take it away from my dock. Like I’m gonna have to completely delete it.

Jeri: Yes.

Em: That's what I had to do.

Rach: ’Cause I–

Christine: Out of sight, out of mind.

Rach: Oh, it was uploading stuff to Patreon–

Jeri: Yeah.

Christine: Ohh.

Rach: –was the last thing that I was like, “I’m going to have a conniption.”

Christine: Uh-huh.

Rach: Took me like two full days, and I was like, “This needs to come out tomorrow.” And then Jeri was like–

Em: [chuckles]

Rach: –“Are you– What browser are you using?”

Christine: Wow.

Rach: And I was like, “Safari.”

Em: “None of your business, Jeri.”

Christine: “None of your business.” [laughs]

Jeri: This is actually an intervention. [laughs]

Christine: [laughs]

Rach: [laughs]

Em: Yeah. [laughs]

Rach: No more.

Christine: Yes, we’ve, we’ve been here before.

Em: Yeah.

Christine: Um, we had to intervene on Em’s behalf one time–

Em: [chuckles]

Christine: –so don’t worry.

Rach: Yeah.

Christine: Uh, wow. Well, thank you both so much for having… us? No. For being–

Rach: You had us. You had us.

Jeri: You had us. [unintelligible]

Christine: –for– Thank you for letting us have you.

Rach: Thank you for having us.

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: You're so welcome. Uh, and also, where can people find you besides just, you know, all over the place?

Rach: We are – I really need to remember these handles better – forbetterandworsepodcast–

Jeri: Pod.

Rach: –po-pod@gmail.

Jeri: Is it pod or–

Rach: Yeah, for be– [laughs]

Jeri: [laughs]

Christine: They both, they both pull their phones out simultaneously.

Em: [laughs]

Rach: [unintelligible] Let me get my shit together.

Jeri: Hey. Hey, hey, hey.

Rach: Let me get my shit together.

Jeri: Just one minute.

Christine: I just know that Eva is about to chime in with all the, all the right information.

Rach: Okay, yeah. On Instagram–

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: –@forbetterandworsepodcast. You can also find us on TikTok at, um–

Jeri: [laughs]

Rach: –forbetterandworse.

Christine: We just have to f– have– Well, Rachel has to find her herself first and then we can find you guys on–

Jeri: Yes. Yeah.

Em: Mm-hmm.

Christine: So find yourself.

Jeri: Yeah. Actually, it’s a geocache situation.

Christine: [laughs]

Jeri: You just have to find coordinates.

Christine: It’s a big scavenger hunt. Yeah.

Jeri: And it’ll lead you where you need to go.

Rach: Exactly. We’ll–

Christine: It’s super fun.

Rach: –put in the hyperlink to the YouTube or something. You know what I mean? Like find us that way.

Em: Love it.

Christine: Oh, you have to open it on Safari–

Rach: [laughs]

Christine: –otherwise it’ll never work.

Jeri: Hey, if you’re meant to find us, we’ll find you.

Rach: Exactly.

Em: Love it.

Christine: That’s so powerful. Wow. What a way to end it. Um, thank you both so much. Uh, what a delight. And, uh, congratulations, Jeri, on being a newlywed. Yay!

Em: [claps]

Rach: Whoo!

Jeri: Yay!

Christine: Whoa.

Rach: [singing] ♪ Her last name is Parsons now, finally. ♪♪

Christine: Oh! Ooh-la-la. Has a nice ring to it.

Rach: JP.

Em: Has a ri-ring to it. [holds up their left hand with their ring finger extended]

Christine: That’s right.

Jeri: Thanks, everyone. Thanks for having us.

Em: [chuckles]

Jeri: A blast as always.

Em: A blast.

Christine: L–

Em: Uh, yeah. Thank you. And we’ll see everyone next month for more listener stories.

Rach: Yay.

Christine: Love you, bye!

Rach: Bye!


Christine Schiefer